The Best Toaster Ovens

Table of Contents

A toaster oven is a versatile small appliance that has found its place in most kitchens. Smaller versions don’t take up much space, while larger models still take up less room than a traditional oven. A basic toaster oven will toast, bake and roast most foods, and more advanced models can act as a convection oven, rotisserie and air fryer.

Toaster ovens are so convenient and use less energy than a conventional oven. Affordably priced, toaster ovens offer ease of use, flexibility and an abundance of features to satisfy most culinary needs.

Read more about toaster ovens you can purchase online to make an informed decision before choosing one for yourself.

1. Editor's Pick: COSORI Toaster Oven & Air Fryer

1. Editor's Pick: COSORI Toaster Oven & Air Fryer
  • Toaster, convection oven, and air-fryer in one
  • Spacious, non-stick interior
  • LED screen, interior light, and two-speed fan
  • Five heating elements
  • Recipe book with 100 recipes
  • More expensive than a regular toaster oven
  • Can get hot, do not place under a cabinet

Key Specs

Brand: COSORI
Item Dimensions: 51.1 x 41.9 x 30.7 cm
Material: Sleek brushed stainless steel
Weight: 20.3 lbs.

For anyone looking for a feature-packed toaster oven that really delivers on its promises, this 30-litre model from Cosori fits the bill. Its large-sized interior can accommodate six pieces of bread, a 13-inch pizza, or an entire chicken. Easy to operate and user-friendly, it’s a toaster oven/air fryer duo that can handle pretty much every culinary adventure with ease — baking, toasting, roasting and dehydrating.

The air-fry function is genius and a go-to for anyone who loves crispy fried food but doesn’t love the fat and extra calories. It’s possible to enjoy air-fried meals with up to 85 per cent less fat than traditionally fried foods. It's important to note that this feature will require more cooking time than a stand-alone air fryer, as the machine has less power than standard air-fryer models.

Still, it's thoughtfully designed with you in mind. It has an intuitive LED screen, convenient dial controls, and good interior lighting. Equipped with 360-degree heat circulation, a two-speed fan, and five smart heating elements, it cooks your food evenly and quickly. Other features and accessories include: a crumb tray; a fry basket; a food tray; a wire rack; a rotisserie fork set and rotisserie handle; a recipe book; and, a non-stick interior.

2. Best Runner Up: Hamilton-Beach 2-in-1 Countertop Oven and 2-Slice Toaster, Stainless Steel (31156)

2. Best Runner Up: Hamilton-Beach 2-in-1 Countertop Oven and 2-Slice Toaster, Stainless Steel (31156)
  • 2-in-1 functions; separate toaster frees up interior space
  • Separate shade selector for toasting preference
  • Two rack positions
  • Interior fits a 9" pizza
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Exterior of oven gets hot

Key Specs

Brand: Hamilton Beach
Model Number: 31156
Product Dimensions: 30.61 x 45.21 x 26.01 cm
Weight: 4.94 kg
Material: Stainless Steel

One of the main functions of a toaster oven is making toast, right? Sounds like a no-brainer but the reality is that when there’s toast in the oven it takes up all the room leaving no space to cook anything else at the same time. We included this toaster oven from Hamilton Beach because the toasting option on the top of the appliance opens up the interior space so when bread is being toasted other foods can also be baking, roasting, or heating up.

That’s not the only reason to like this machine, however. Having the toaster and oven together saves counter space, since there is no need for a separate pop-up toaster. Plus, bread in the toaster section toasts faster, more evenly, and with a better consistency than if it was inside the oven. There is even a separate shade selector to determine just how toasted the bread should be for individual tastes.

Easy to use, just select the toast or oven option before operating. Other features include: bake and broil functions in the oven; a 60-minute timer with auto shutoff; an extra-wide toasting slot to fit bagels and artisan breads; an interior that fits a nine-inch pizza; two rack positions; and, a removable crumb tray, rack, and bake pan.

3. Best Budget Pick: Black and Decker TO1313SBD Toaster Oven

3. Best Budget Pick: Black and Decker TO1313SBD Toaster Oven
  • Affordable and compact
  • Four cooking functions: bake, broil, toast and keep warm
  • 30-minute timer with stay-on function
  • EvenToast technology
  • Includes baking pan, broiler pan, and removable crumb tray
  • Only one height for the rack
  • No interior light

Key Specs

Brand: BLACK + DECKER
Model Number: TO1313SBD
Product Dimensions: 24.13 x 41.66 x 23.88 cm
Material: Stainless Steel
Item Weight: 2.27 kg

Toaster ovens are so convenient, but when staying in budget is key it’s not always easy to find an affordable model that will function well and stand the test of time. Black + Decker has been making toaster ovens for decades and have perfected the formula to include a budget-priced model that ticks off all the boxes for reliable performance as well as some pretty interesting features.

This compact, versatile toaster oven offers up four cooking functions: bake, broil, toast, and keeping food warm, with a heat factor of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. Although it is compact and won’t take much space on the countertop, it is roomy enough to separately toast four slices of bread or heat up a nine-inch pizza. With the included baking pan and broiler pan, it can also be used to bake muffins, roast a chicken breast and more.

Other features include a 30-minute timer with a stay-on function; toast, broil, bake and keep-warm controls; a removable crumb tray; and an exclusive EvenToast technology that optimizes heat distribution for more evenly toasted bread.

4. Best All-Purpose: Toshiba AC25CEW-BS Digital Toaster Oven

4. Best All-Purpose: Toshiba AC25CEW-BS Digital Toaster Oven
  • Spacious, non-stick interior
  • Fits six slices of toast, 12-inch pizza
  • Convection oven and rotisserie functions
  • Large LED digital display
  • Easy to turn control knobs
  • Crumb tray can be difficult to remove for cleaning
  • No interior light

Key Specs

Brand: Toshiba
Item Dimensions: 48.2 x 39.6 x 27.4 cm
Material: Stainless Steel
Item Weight: 16.21 lbs.

When the need is greater than just toasting bread or heating up pizza, a toaster oven can perform a variety of functions to handle many kinds of cooking tasks without using the same amount of energy, or taking up as much space, as a traditional oven.

This 1500-watt digital toaster oven from Toshiba offers up a nice-sized interior to accommodate more elaborate meals so you can enjoy food like roast chicken using the convection or rotisserie functions. The convection feature circulates the heat evenly to promote quicker cooking times, while the rotisserie slowly rotates meat while it’s cooking to promote uniform browning and a crispy skin.

The easy-to-use digital panel has nine preset cooking settings, taking the guesswork out of timing. From toast, bake, and defrost to broil and reheat it’s all there with a single touch. There really isn’t much this small appliance can’t handle - especially with an interior that can accommodate six slices of bread, a 12-inch pizza, a casserole, or a four-pound chicken.

Other convenient features include: three easy-turn control knobs; a removable crumb tray; a rotisserie kit and lifter; a baking rack; a baking pan; a rack clamp; and, a non-stick interior surface.

5. Also Consider: Oster TSSTTVMNDG Digital Convection Toaster Oven

5. Also Consider: Oster TSSTTVMNDG Digital Convection Toaster Oven
  • Large family size interior with light
  • 90-minute timer and automatic shutoff
  • Digital control panel
  • Seven pre-set cooking functions
  • Two rack positions
  • Exterior handle can get hot

Key Specs

Brand: Oster
Item Dimensions: 41.4 x 50 x 28.7 cm
Material: Stainless Steel
Item Weight: 20.3 lbs.

With a large family to feed, it’s important to have the right equipment that is spacious to accommodate enough food to feed a crowd. Often a larger size equals a bigger price tag but this large capacity model from Oster is big on space and gentle on the wallet.

This countertop oven comes equipped with convection technology, which means it distributes heat quickly and evenly for thorough cooking and excellent results. The oven provides an extra-large interior that can accommodate six slices of bread, a frozen pizza, a whole chicken, or a casserole, and even a 13 by 9-inch pan of crescent rolls or chocolate-chip cookies. The two rack positions are also particularly helpful when cooking a tall roast or turkey.

The sleek, modern-looking toaster oven features a stainless-finish frame and a user-friendly manual/digital control panel for convenient operation and makes it easy to choose from a variety of preset cooking functions, including bake, convection bake, broil, toast, pizza, defrost, and warm.

Other features include: a removable external crumb tray; one-touch controls to adjust time and temperature; an optional interior light; a baking pan; a 90-minute timer; an automatic shutoff feature; and, an easy-to-clean interior.

What to Look for When Choosing a Toaster Oven

Size: Toaster ovens come in a variety of sizes, from compact to spacious. The size you choose will depend on two factors: how much room you have on the countertop and how much food you want to heat up, bake or cook at the same time. For tiny spaces, compact toaster ovens can be really handy and can still have extra features like convection capabilities and broiling. If you want to use a toaster oven more frequently than a regular oven, you have a repertoire of meals and recipes and a large family to feed, then purchase a model that will hold larger cookware and quantities of food.

Use: Another factor that will determine which toaster oven you should purchase is how you will use it. If you need it just to make toast and heat up frozen pizza and frozen dinners, then a basic model will do. If you prefer to use it more like a conventional oven, more sophisticated models offer up features that let you cook more complicated meals, like a whole roasted chicken or fried foods. To reduce the number of appliances you have, you can choose a multi-functional model with air fryer and rotisserie capabilities.

Features: Aside from the standard functions, there are some extra features to consider that may make your cooking experience more pleasant. A toaster oven that has a pop-up toaster and oven incorporated into one is a great space saver, allowing you to toast bread or bagels and cook food in the oven at the same time. A crumb tray that is easy to remove and clean doesn’t sound like much of a feature, but accumulated crumbs at the bottom of a toaster oven will eventually burn and smell. Removing the tray completely to clean makes good sense. If you plan to cook foods with some height, like a chicken or turkey, it’s nice to have a rack that offers two positions, one low and one high, so that the poultry can fit in without touching the upper burner element. Other convenient features include a timer, automatic shutoff, pre-set cooking options and an interior light to better see inside the toaster oven.

Price: Like most things, toaster ovens are available in a wide range of prices to suit most budgets and needs. It’s never a good idea to spend more than you can afford, so consider carefully how you will use the toaster oven before choosing a model. As a general rule of thumb, the more features a toaster oven will have, the more expensive it will be. Also brand name toaster ovens may also be pricier, but not always. Keep in mind that higher priced toaster ovens may also include a good warranty, which is important if you plan to keep your toaster oven for a long time.

RedFlagDeals.com is reader-supported. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and other similar affiliate advertising programs. These programs are designed to provide a way for sites to earn advertising fees by linking to them. This means that RedFlagDeals.com will sometimes get a small commission if you make a purchase through our links.