TOP CHEF thread

[shannn]

The Top Chef Thread

Top Chef Season 6
Info: http://www.bravotv.com/whos-who-meet-the-chefs

---------------------------------------

Previous Winners (in white for those who haven't seen them yet) :
Season 1 - Harold
Season 2 - Ilan
Season 3 - Hung
Season 4 - Stephanie
Season 5 - Hosea

---------------------------------------


NOTE: Hey everyone, updated the thead so we could discuss Top Chef

[mdc]

I've been catching it whenever I can ... I can't believe that chick who looks like a ferret is still in. Nothing I have seen her produce has been good and she always has an excuse ...

I love the show ... I wish Hell's Kitchen would be as serious as Top Chef because I think Ramsey would be great in a serious setting (especially when you see his non-American shows and the quality of them)

[shannn]

I've been catching it whenever I can ... I can't believe that chick who looks like a ferret is still in. Nothing I have seen her produce has been good and she always has an excuse ...

I love the show ... I wish Hell's Kitchen would be as serious as Top Chef because I think Ramsey would be great in a serious setting (especially when you see his non-American shows and the quality of them)

It would be hilarious to have Ramsey guest star as a judge, and have the show unrated air, lol

Haha, and yea, I know what you mean about Carla...surprised she didn't get the boot last episode

[victory01]

I'm liking the show. Pretty easy to follow since Food Network tends to replay a lot of episodes throughout the week. Stephon has shown to be pretty talented and consistent and I think he might take it, even though he seems to be a stubborn ass. Plus there has only been one season where the winner of the first challenge didn't take it all.

I'm waiting for the reunion ep. to find out if the 2 chefs that made out got dumped by their spouses back home. What a stupid mistake.

[basilmurphy]

I really love Top Chef, cause while it's still a reality show, and there are sometimes silly reality show things, it feels like the main focus is on the chefs and the food.

I enjoy Hell's Kitchen too, but it feels more like american idol for chefs rather than about food (or even a restaurant).

[doubloonie]

I watch both Top Chef and Hell's Kitchen and Top Chef by far is the higher caliber show. I'm rooting for Fabio. Unfortunately, his cooking hasn't been getting great results lately but I love his personality - his comments/interviews crack me up! I can see Stephan winning though as his dishes/concepts seems to be much more sophisticated than most of the contestants on the show. I also can't wait to see what happens to Hosia and Lea during the reunion show. Such a dumb move on both their parts, but great drama! :)

[MaximDude]

I like Top Chef alot, but Hell's Kitchen is only ok. For me, I like watching a show where people can actually cook! In Top Chef, people can come up with their own unique dishes, but in HK people can't even make pasta or grill a piece of meat properly. :lol:

For TC, Stefan is definitely the one to beat. I can only see Hosea or possible Jamie or Fabio making a challenge to him and no one else.

For HK, its kinda annoying to see Ramsey yelling almost constantly. I think to be successful on that show, all you have to do is:

- know how to cook food properly
- know how to make a good monk fish and risotto
- know a little on how to run a kitchen and delegate responsibility

And you're probably more than halfway to winning.

[shannn]

I'm waiting for the reunion ep. to find out if the 2 chefs that made out got dumped by their spouses back home. What a stupid mistake.

Serious, lol

I wanna know her reaction especially towards Hosea's comments about how he was going to "throw her under the bus" (as they like to say on the show) if their team went down

Should be fun, lol

Kinda hope Fabio wins...Stefan cooks incredible food, but is incredibly cocky
I think it will end up being Fabio, Jeff, Jamie and Stefan in the finals...or maybe Hosea instead of Fabio/Jeff...but those guys seem to be on top most of the time

Can't wait for Wednesday night to see a new episode!

[NDman]

Another vote for Fabio. He is so much fun to watch, though he has been struggling the past few weeks already; and next week doesn't look all that promising for him either based on the preview. Having that said, I am pretty sure Bravo will try to recruit Fabio onto the Top Chef tour after it's all said and done. His character will be an asset to the tour without a doubt.

I don't see Jeff making it too much further. Eventually his "bit off more than he could chew" mistake will catch up to him. Every time he tries to do too much and it almost cost him a few times already. Yet he still never learned. I too agreed Stefan has a good chance, though his personality sucks big time

Leah got bailed out by Fabio and Stefan during the restaurant war for sure. And Hosea speaks out (http://www.bravotv.com/Top_Chef/season/5/blogs/index.php?blog=burning_questions_2&article=2009/01/hosea_responds) (they broke up, for reason unspecified. But you can bet the incident played a big role, and it sounded that way)

[scan]

Anyone else getting sick of that lesbian? She's so full of herself it makes me sick at times. Like when she won the challenge with the scallop dish she exhales "finally!".

[kgen]

Anyone else getting sick of that lesbian? She's so full of herself it makes me sick at times. Like when she won the challenge with the scallop dish she exhales "finally!".

"Come on! This is Top Chef, not Top Scallop!"
Fabio's character is hilarious -- definitely makes this season worth watching. I don't get why everyone hates Stefan though -- even if he's arrogant, he clearly knows how to cook and they should be taking advantage of that, no?

[victory01]

"Come on! This is Top Chef, not Top Scallop!"
Fabio's character is hilarious -- definitely makes this season worth watching. I don't get why everyone hates Stefan though -- even if he's arrogant, he clearly knows how to cook and they should be taking advantage of that, no?

He just seems hard to work with. I remember a few episodes back he was bagging the crap out of Jeff for making a tomato dessert or something. Stephan wouldn't shut up about his experience and how it would be impossible to plate. It ended up being the best dish in the whole challenge. Then the last episode where he wouldn't tell anyone what his desserts were going to be. Pretty frustrating to be on the same team with someone who isn't a team player. I mean his dish can help you win, but his attitude could destroy you teams moral.

[slowtyper]

I love Top Chef but this season is really really dull...I'm not even interested in it (but of course I will keep watching). The skill level of this season seems to be a lot lower than last season as well. Last year Richard was just amazing.

[bembol]

This is now my favortie TV Show, season keeps getting better.

My top three are Stefan, Fabio and Leah. I love the last episode I can't believe they do not know how to play the game and use Stefan to their advantage. I wasn't surprised the Radhika went home because she doesn't have the leadership.

[shannn]

I love Top Chef but this season is really really dull...I'm not even interested in it (but of course I will keep watching). The skill level of this season seems to be a lot lower than last season as well. Last year Richard was just amazing.

IMO, I don't think many people can top Richard, because he was bringing in something relatively new (molecular gastronomy I believe ... playing around with science and food)...but I think Fabio has it in him
I remember he had those olives that exploded in your mouth in one episode, that was kind of neat...hopefully he'll do more of that (instead of screwing up)

And yea, Stefan is arrogant...the only thing that may bring him down are team challenges, but, he's proven many times that it would take a lot more than others screwing up for him to lose (like restaurant wars)


BTW, does anyone else find Toby Young realllllly annoying? He seems liek he tries reallly hard to come up with his comments, and they usually come out of left field. I wish Gail came back, or if Ted Simmons (or maybe Gordon Ramsay, lol) became the judge

Anyway, tonight's episode --> Top Chef superstars versus current Top Chefs...looks interesting

[NDman]

BTW, does anyone else find Toby Young realllllly annoying? He seems liek he tries reallly hard to come up with his comments, and they usually come out of left field. I wish Gail came back, or if Ted Simmons (or maybe Gordon Ramsay, lol) became the judge

I agreed your comments Toby Young in general. But I wouldn't go as far as saying he's annoying. He is supposed to be and told to be abrasive. That said, I found this a peculiar choice since they already have a blunt critic in Tom. That's just a clash of style. They need to balance things out instead of having 2 "bad guys" on the judging panel.

It was great before with Gail. Tom's the bad ass with some sharp comments. Padma is nice but doesn't offer much in terms of comments, Gail is somewhere in between. Though I do enjoy Young's dark British humours

[victory01]

Speaking of judges, I always wonder what Padma's qualifications are. Don't get me wrong, shes a good host and is easy on the eyes but as a judge?

I remember an episode in a past season she was promoting a book which was a collection of recipes that she had tasted over the years. Not created, she just liked certain dishes and wanted to put together a book full of their recipes. Me and my girlfriend had a good laugh at that.

[scan]

Speaking of judges, I always wonder what Padma's qualifications are. Don't get me wrong, shes a good host and is easy on the eyes but as a judge?

I remember an episode in a past season she was promoting a book which was a collection of recipes that she had tasted over the years. Not created, she just liked certain dishes and wanted to put together a book full of their recipes. Me and my girlfriend had a good laugh at that.

I have always thought this. I really don't take what she says about the food with any consideration. She is easy on the eyes though :cheesygri

[mdc]

Speaking of judges, I always wonder what Padma's qualifications are. Don't get me wrong, shes a good host and is easy on the eyes but as a judge?

I remember an episode in a past season she was promoting a book which was a collection of recipes that she had tasted over the years. Not created, she just liked certain dishes and wanted to put together a book full of their recipes. Me and my girlfriend had a good laugh at that.

amen!

Everytime she bad mouths a chef on the show I always roll my eyes ... as far as I can see, she has no real talent other than looking decent and memorizing what she has to say during the challenges ... who is she to judge ANYTHING?

[shannn]

Speaking of judges, I always wonder what Padma's qualifications are. Don't get me wrong, shes a good host and is easy on the eyes but as a judge?

Reading wikipedia and from what my mom told me...she married this really rich guy (I think he was big in the oil industry) who was older than her father...divorced him and got a lot of money...and she modelled for a while, lol
I guess that makes her a food critic, lol

--------------------------------------

Wow, did you guys see the latest episode? (It's in white below for those who have not yet)

I can't believe what happened, I guess my guesses for the final is out the window, Jeff is GONE! I honestly thought Fabio was gone for sure...I swear it was his charm that got him trhough. Jeff kind of has this cocky swagger with him...I don't think the judges appreciated it, plus he is realllly stubborn, and tends to overcomplicate his dishes

And wow, the judges seemed displeased that it was Stefan, JEff and Fabio at the bottom...Honestly, I'm surprised Leah survived again, this time overcooking her fish...wow

And it looked like Ariane had no pants on during the show, lol

WOW, what an episode...can't wait til the next one!

[victory01]

Great, now I'm starting to hate her.....

I did. I don't know how to change the font to white, so those who missed it.....try not to read.


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


The elimination challenge was a pretty good idea but the judging scheme was a joke. It was clever in a high school project kind of way but lame in terms of serious chefs competing in a competition. They would have split decisions and then have the fans vote, but they have no criteria to vote them on. Were they fans of football/home cooking or fans of cuisine? Big curve ball. Probably why the more sophisticated chefs failed. Happy they beat the all stars though!

It was a shame that some of the best chefs had to go to elimination. I would think its tough for Europeans with high end cooking backgrounds to go to America and try to understand football/home cooking. I like Fabio's passion when defending his dish though. I think it was a little more fired up cause it was against the guest judge who poked fun at his dish from the first challenge, which he took to heart.

Either way the grand prize kicked ASS! I'm sure shes gonna win huge points with her husband.

and was Ariane in the purple jersey?? cause yeah......pantsless! lol

[MaximDude]

Personally, I wonder why you need 'experience' to be a food critic? I mean as long as you know what tastes good to you and what doesn't, that's all that should matter. I like Padma and I think she's a good host and just because she doesn't have the same background as other people, doesn't mean she can't be a food critic too.

As for last night's show, I was abit surprised that Jeff was kicked off considering Fabio was getting reamed for his cooking of the venison. Thought he'd be gone for sure, but lucky for him he got a second chance. And it was fun to see Stefan be so sure he was going to kick Andrea's ass and then he himself gets owned in the elimination challenge. :lol:

[slowtyper]

I believe Padma has her own cookbook. Not sure what other qualifications she has, but she seems to have a sophisticated palate.

I agreed your comments Toby Young in general. But I wouldn't go as far as saying he's annoying. He is supposed to be and told to be abrasive. That said, I found this a peculiar choice since they already have a blunt critic in Tom. That's just a clash of style. They need to balance things out instead of having 2 "bad guys" on the judging panel.


I read somewhere that mentioned Tom's Blog...I didn't read it myself, but Tom said that Toby initially thought he was brought on to be the smartass and soon realized during judging that the competition was much more serious than that. I was hopeful that his first episode was just a bust and soon after he would actually start contributing but so far he brings absolutely nothing except memorizing a few cringe-worthy comments and waiting for opportunities to use them. "weapons of mass destruction?" oh come on....get out of here and bring back Bourdain or Ted!

[shannn]

Great, now I'm starting to hate her.....

Anyone catch the episode last night?


The elimination challenge was a pretty good idea but the judging scheme was a joke. It was clever in a high school project kind of way but lame in terms of serious chefs competing in a competition. They would have split decisions and then have the fans vote, but they have no criteria to vote them on. Were they fans of football/home cooking or fans of cuisine? Big curve ball.

It was a shame that some of the best chefs had to go to elimination. I would think its tough for Europeans with high end cooking backgrounds to go to America and try to understand football/home cooking. I like Fabio's passion when defending his dish though. I think it was a little more fired up cause it was against the guest judge who poked fun at his dish from the first challenge, which he took to heart.

At least Padma is nice to look at :lol: well...from most angles...
And IMO, she kind of brings a "lay" attitude to the critiquing...critiquing on overall taste, whereas the other judges find the smaller details to critique.
And her judgment is pretty good. She is often the first person to vocally judge each dish, and the other judges mostly agree with her

Yea, I didn't really like this episode...I thought it was kind of stupid, because you could have had one of the best dishes but still be put up for elimination, and that is what happened. The 3 dishes that lost were honestly not that bad...it seemed like (for the most part, besides Fabio's) that they had to find something wrong with it instead of critiquing it for what it was...

I think Fabio's swagger got him through...Jeff has that cocky snobby swagger, and I think the judges got tired of seeing him do too much and ruining his otherwise well done dishes...

Personally, I wonder why you need 'experience' to be a food critic? I mean as long as you know what tastes good to you and what doesn't, that's all that should matter. I like Padma and I think she's a good host and just because she doesn't have the same background as other people, doesn't mean she can't be a food critic too.

As for last night's show, I was abit surprised that Jeff was kicked off considering Fabio was getting reamed for his cooking of the venison. Thought he'd be gone for sure, but lucky for him he got a second chance. And it was fun to see Stefan be so sure he was going to kick Andrea's ass and then he himself gets owned in the elimination challenge. :lol:

I agree, Padma knows what tastes good. With so many seasons passing by, I can't really see the show with another host other than herself (with Tom)

Yea, I for sure thought Fabio was gone...I wonder if they kept him for ratings? B/c I'm sure they knew that if Fabio was eliminated, a LOT of fans would be dissapointed

And I really liked Stefan's continued cockiness during the elimination, he looked shocked, lol. Plus, he kept saying that he was safe b/c it was his first time, haha, I wish they just played a joke on him and told him he was eliminated...the look on his face would have been priceless, lol

[victory01]

Personally, I wonder why you need 'experience' to be a food critic? I mean as long as you know what tastes good to you and what doesn't, that's all that should matter. I like Padma and I think she's a good host and just because she doesn't have the same background as other people, doesn't mean she can't be a food critic too.



But then it might come down to personal preference. They are trying to be subjective. Bottom line is yeah, it has to taste good. But what happens when all the dishes taste good? Then you have to take into consideration the technique, vision, what the chefs are trying to accomplish, etc. The other judges who are trained chefs and restaurant owners can not only taste if the food is good, but ultimately judge the chefs themselves.

EDIT...if you guys like her so much...hehe
http://bravotv.seenon.com/detail.php?p=83171

[shannn]

But then it might come down to personal preference. They are trying to be subjective. Bottom line is yeah, it has to taste good. But what happens when all the dishes taste good? Then you have to take into consideration the technique, vision, what the chefs are trying to accomplish, etc. The other judges who are trained chefs and restaurant owners can not only taste if the food is good, but ultimately judge the chefs themselves.

EDIT...if you guys like her so much...hehe
http://bravotv.seenon.com/detail.php?p=83171

lol

I was thinking of getting one of those shirts

But yea, honestly, I don't think Padma has much say in who stays and who goes...I think she was just put there for eye candy purposes...and to point out some obvious things...

[NDman]

I too agree that the development was great last night, but the judging part was very weak. It is funny how Stefan's downfall was his own cockiness and Jeff's for his over-thinking, again.

They must have put some consideration into Fabio's character for making that decision (makes for much better TV than Jeff would). I am glad that he got a big slice of humble pie from the guest judge and hope he'd wake up from that. "Field goal! Uh ya!!" That was hilarious

Leah got luck again. Her competitor probably did a lot worse than she did. Yikes

[slowtyper]

I too agree that the development was great last night, but the judging part was very weak. It is funny how Stefan's downfall was his own cockiness and Jeff's for his over-thinking, again.

They must have put some consideration into Fabio's character for making that decision (makes for much better TV than Jeff would). I am glad that he got a big slice of humble pie from the guest judge and hope he'd wake up from that. "Field goal! Uh ya!!" That was hilarious

Leah got luck again. Her competitor probably did a lot worse than she did. Yikes

There are tons of "top chef conspiracies" as to whether or not the producers make decisions based on ratings and IMO, I'm pretty sure that they do NOT do any of this.

[victory01]

I too agree that the development was great last night, but the judging part was very weak. It is funny how Stefan's downfall was his own cockiness and Jeff's for his over-thinking, again.

They must have put some consideration into Fabio's character for making that decision (makes for much better TV than Jeff would). I am glad that he got a big slice of humble pie from the guest judge and hope he'd wake up from that. "Field goal! Uh ya!!" That was hilarious

Leah got luck again. Her competitor probably did a lot worse than she did. Yikes

Yeah! I loved how Stephan kept bagging on the all star, Andrea? Kept saying that she hopefully learned how to cook since she lost and what not. Hilarious. Hosea also mentioned how Stephan would always bring up old wins with commentary...I wonder if other chefs will bring up this loss with commentary. "Hey Stephan! Remember when you won the challenge and had first pick? And kept bagging on your pick? And then lost in the sweep? REMEMBER??"

[MaximDude]

At least Padma is nice to look at :lol: well...from most angles...

I thought she looked really hot in her referee top in yesterdays show. :cheesygri


Yea, I didn't really like this episode...I thought it was kind of stupid, because you could have had one of the best dishes but still be put up for elimination, and that is what happened. The 3 dishes that lost were honestly not that bad...it seemed like (for the most part, besides Fabio's) that they had to find something wrong with it instead of critiquing it for what it was...

I think Fabio's swagger got him through...Jeff has that cocky snobby swagger, and I think the judges got tired of seeing him do too much and ruining his otherwise well done dishes...

I really liked yesterday's show actually. It was fun to see past season's competitors comeback to go up against this season's chefs. I liked seeing Stefan go abit gaga over Andrea. "Andrea, I love you, call me" :lol: And I also liked seeing Hosea going up against Miguel and saying "I want you to like me so you won't feel as bad when I beat you" and then he wins 10-0. :D

Also with regards to who was selected for elimination yesterday, it was whoever lost their individual round would be up for elimination and only Stefan, Fabio and Jeff lost. Makes me wonder how they would choose if everyone won their rounds?


And I really liked Stefan's continued cockiness during the elimination, he looked shocked, lol. Plus, he kept saying that he was safe b/c it was his first time, haha, I wish they just played a joke on him and told him he was eliminated...the look on his face would have been priceless, lol

Well I think there was zero chance that Stefan was going home last night and he knew it. It was his first time in the bottom and he's pretty much the best chef this season from day one with Hosea right there with him. But it definitely would have been funny if Stefan was sent packing. :lol:

But then it might come down to personal preference. They are trying to be subjective. Bottom line is yeah, it has to taste good. But what happens when all the dishes taste good? Then you have to take into consideration the technique, vision, what the chefs are trying to accomplish, etc. The other judges who are trained chefs and restaurant owners can not only taste if the food is good, but ultimately judge the chefs themselves.


After hosting the past few seasons, I think Padma should be qualified enough by now to judge all of the things you've listed above. Also it seems like that although she might get a say in things, who knows if she's actually involved in the final judgement as to who goes home and who wins even if she is capable?

I too agree that the development was great last night, but the judging part was very weak. It is funny how Stefan's downfall was his own cockiness and Jeff's for his over-thinking, again.

They must have put some consideration into Fabio's character for making that decision (makes for much better TV than Jeff would). I am glad that he got a big slice of humble pie from the guest judge and hope he'd wake up from that. "Field goal! Uh ya!!" That was hilarious

Leah got luck again. Her competitor probably did a lot worse than she did. Yikes

From the looks of things, Fabio isn't going to last much longer anyway you cut it. I think he might last longer than Leah, but then after that he might be gone if Carla and Jamie keep their game up. Hosea and Stefan are pretty much locks to be in the finals.

At the beginning of this season, I thought Fabio would be a top contender but after watching him the past few weeks, he hasn't really done much to make me think he can win it all now. He's been in the bottom a few times and otherwise he's been in the middle. I don't remember him ever winning an elimination challenge.

Also as an aside, everytime I look at Jamie, I can't help but think of Katee Sackhoff from Battlestar Galatica. :)

[blarg]

Mmm....Padma in Foot Locker uniform

[Brandon]

Jeff getting kicked out is expected. He always has too many components in dishes and he hasn't been able to perfect whole dishes. Either part of it sucks and it just tarnishes the rest of the dish, or some components are deemed unnecessary by the judges. It's like he doesn't know what to make, so he makes 3-4 things (which screws up the quality since he has more work to do).

I'm guessing the finale will be Hosea, Stefan and Carla.

Does anybody else find Carla kinda scary? The expressions she makes with her face sometimes are kinda weird... and it's hilarious that scenes are cut to show it even more.

Padma is definitely a good looker as host. Any comments on this? :lol:
http://www.bestweekever.tv/2007/01/26/bwe-exclusive-padma-lakshmi-is-a-literal-pothead/

[NDman]

:arrowu: My wife and I were saying the exact same thing about Carla. Her eyes are ready to pop out everytime she speaks. If you noticed (don't think it happened this week), the like to cut to funky music whenever they add Carla's clips/commentary

I thought she was gonna get nailed by the whole "love" thing this week as Tom seems to be pretty annoyed by that term most of the time. But instead Toby Young made light of it and joked about it. That was pretty funny

[victory01]

Jeff getting kicked out is expected. He always has too many components in dishes and he hasn't been able to perfect whole dishes. Either part of it sucks and it just tarnishes the rest of the dish, or some components are deemed unnecessary by the judges. It's like he doesn't know what to make, so he makes 3-4 things (which screws up the quality since he has more work to do).

I'm guessing the finale will be Hosea, Stefan and Carla.

Does anybody else find Carla kinda scary? The expressions she makes with her face sometimes are kinda weird... and it's hilarious that scenes are cut to show it even more.

Padma is definitely a good looker as host. Any comments on this? :lol:
http://www.bestweekever.tv/2007/01/26/bwe-exclusive-padma-lakshmi-is-a-literal-pothead/

I agree, it seemed like Jeff did a whole bunch of crap just to use it as a scape goat if need be. His defense was always listing all the technical components and how much work he put into it. Not a bad trick, it's better than cooking simple food poorly, no excuses there. It worked for a while, but the judges caught on.

Carlo is a monster sometimes. Her smile is even scary, and I have been worried that her eyes might pop right out of her head.

I don't think Padma lights up on set. If she does I think she's doing a great job of hiding it. She's not getting ripped, that's for sure.

[Brandon]

I don't think Padma lights up on set. If she does I think she's doing a great job of hiding it. She's not getting ripped, that's for sure.

Looking back at some of the old seasons, there were a few where she made empty/blank faces or looked zone out (focused on something that she shouldn't be). And sometimes she likes dishes that nobody else (the pro's) like, and I mean when you have the munchies your standards go a bit lower. :lol:

But who knows.

[shannn]

I'm guessing the finale will be Hosea, Stefan and Carla.

Carla? Really? I think her lack of confidence may catch up with her...

I'm still banking on Fabio to make a comeback, lol
He's honestly one of my fave contestants on Top Chef all time (along with Hung, lol, that guy was amazingly fast...and maybe Richard and Ilan)

[-=Wraith=-]

Before Jeff's elimination, I would've guessed Stefan, Fabio, Jamie, and Jeff for the finale....

As for the other three, I really don't see any of them having the skills to actually win top chef.

[tyrrell]

Love this show.

Too bad I missed last weeks episode.

I'm going to bet that Jamie is going to win it all.

I prefer the girl who was the host of season 1 over Padma.

[bembol]

Jeff wad one of my favorites and it finally caught up with him doing too much. Even if he made it to the finale, I think he wouldn't win it because of it.

I'm happy though that Stefan and Fabio are still in it. That was the worst Elimination from the entire series so far.

[shannn]

That was the worst Elimination from the entire series so far.

+1

But now it gets interesting...almost down to finals, just a month letf

Predictions now that JEff is gone?

[Brandon]

Personally, I don't even think Jeff was good (compared to who is left, he's in the middle of all contestants). He was only a judge favourite 3 times, and one of those times he was at the 'bottom' of the favourites.

I think Stefan and Hosea are locked in for the finale, with the third being either "scary Carla", Jamie or Fabio (I hope it's him).

[shannn]

Personally, I don't even think Jeff was good (compared to who is left, he's in the middle of all contestants). He was only a judge favourite 3 times, and one of those times he was at the 'bottom' of the favourites.

I think Stefan and Hosea are locked in for the finale, with the third being either "scary Carla", Jamie or Fabio (I hope it's him).

Hmm, I agree with Stefan being a shoe in for the finals..
Hosea...I don't know, he seems kinda shook whenever he is in Leah's vicinity...
Jamie has alwyas been good, so I think she's good
Leah is gonna get eliminated, so is Carla....Unfortunately, Fabio may go as well if he doesn't pick it up

I think it is down to Stefan or Jamie ... but I'm rooting for Fabio

[bembol]

I think its pretty tight race but my favorite is Stefan. He just got cocky going up against Andrea but he dominated fro the beginning.

He is pure jokes, I love that he has a thing for Jamie knowing that she's a lesbian. LOL

[NDman]

He is pure jokes, I love that he has a thing for Jamie knowing that she's a lesbian. LOL
He's just a horny dude. He kind of had hots for Andrea too. Probably with the exception of Carla, he's had a crush on everyone. :D

[shannn]

I think its pretty tight race but my favorite is Stefan. He just got cocky going up against Andrea but he dominated fro the beginning.

He is pure jokes, I love that he has a thing for Jamie knowing that she's a lesbian. LOL

He's just a horny dude. He kind of had hots for Andrea too. Probably with the exception of Carla, he's had a crush on everyone. :D

LOL that is so true

I remember that one episode where he was intentionally pissing her off b/c he thought she was cute when she is angry, haha
What an ass, lol
But...he can cook, lol, and that is all that matters in this competition

One season, I hope they have someone who is madly in love w/ Padma, hahaha, that would be jokes to see how he would try to win her over, lol

[cmx1o1]

im rooting for fabio too. funny guy to watch and some of his comments are hilliarious

"if they gonna give me a monkey ass to fill with fried banana, ill come up with something anyway" lol

but i think stefan is gonna win

[shannn]

O M GGGGGGG, WTH???

(if you did not watch the newest episode yet, don't highlight below / quote my text, or you'll see who got eliminated)

JAMIE ELIMINATED?!?!??!?! Man, how did LEAH dodge ANOTHER BULLET?
Honestly?!?!?!? IT was a coin flip, and LEAH again managers to dodge elimination...if she makes it to the final 4, o m g!!!
I mean, she literally gave up twice in this episode, and you are letting go one of hte best chefs this season over her???????

BTW, lol, Tom seemed annoyed at Toby's comments near the end of hte show, lol

But WTH??? How did Leah NOT GO HOME?!?!? Man, seriously...
/rant

EDIT: Oh yea, BTW, Stefan won, what a surprise, lol
And Padma....was as useless as ever in this show, lol


arrrgggggh

man...Fabio FTW, that's all I gotta say

[victory01]

I KNEW I was supposed to watch something on Wednesdays. Now I'm gonna have to stay up and watch the 2am re-run. Thanks for reminding me though!

[shannn]

I KNEW I was supposed to watch something on Wednesdays. Now I'm gonna have to stay up and watch the 2am re-run. Thanks for reminding me though!

lol, np

my Wednesday routine now a dyas is get home from the library just in time to watch top chef...come on RFD and see what's going down...then get ready for tmr

man...this episode really pissed me off at the end...I relaly can't friggin believe it...but you'll see ;)

[MaximDude]

Kiinda shocked to see Jamie go as I thought for sure this time it'd be Leah. But it doesn't matter as I'm pretty sure its going to be her, Fabio or Carla going next time around.

In the end, no matter who's left, this is still Stefan's prize to lose and this week proves it once again. I can only see Hosea and maybe Carla with an outside shot of challenging him, but really I think its a two horse race between Hosea and Stefan. No one else has been as consistently good as those two. Even if Jamie stuck around, I don't know if she'd be able to compete with Hosea or Stefan.

[shannn]

Kiinda shocked to see Jamie go as I thought for sure this time it'd be Leah. But it doesn't matter as I'm pretty sure its going to be her, Fabio or Carla going next time around.

In the end, no matter who's left, this is still Stefan's prize to lose and this week proves it once again. I can only see Hosea and maybe Carla with an outside shot of challenging him, but really I think its a two horse race between Hosea and Stefan. No one else has been as consistently good as those two. Even if Jamie stuck around, I don't know if she'd be able to compete with Hosea or Stefan.

Oh, but you forget! If there were scallops in the later rounds, it would be Top Scallop and Jamie would win! :lol:

Still, I think Jamie had a better chance than Carla...but Carla is starting come on strong (now that she has confidence)

Let's hope Stefan (or maybe some will not hope) that he will not burn in the finals like Richard did last season

[NDman]

Jamie must have completely butchered the dish in terms of taste because conceptually, she got it right. I thought Leah was gonna be sent home after the fact that she quit in the Quick Fire, even Tom brought it up too. That's too bad. I just can't stand Leah. It always sounds like she seems quite clueless on a lot of things and not motivated enough to do anything great.

Nice rebound from Fabio and Stefan

[victory01]

Jamie was top 3 in my opinion. She kinda looks like Angelina Jolie sometimes.....eyes and lips have their moments. Gonna miss her. I admire her honesty when saying the lunch was boring for her instead of auto kissing ass.

The challenge I thought was very creative, how they surprised them. Always a catch.
I hated how Stefan stated he picked the lobster cause it was his favorite. Just admit it was easiest. Only an idiot would pick a good tasting dish over an easier one in a challenge, unless it happened to be both, in that case just shut up.

Leah won't last. Hosea is losing it while Carla seems to be picking up steam. Should be a good run to the finish, but I have to agree it's Stefan's competition to lose.

[MaximDude]

Jamie was top 3 in my opinion. She kinda looks like Angelina Jolie sometimes.....eyes and lips have their moments. Gonna miss her. I admire her honesty when saying the lunch was boring for her instead of auto kissing ass.

The challenge I thought was very creative, how they surprised them. Always a catch.
I hated how Stefan stated he picked the lobster cause it was his favorite. Just admit it was easiest. Only an idiot would pick a good tasting dish over an easier one in a challenge, unless it happened to be both, in that case just shut up.

Leah won't last. Hosea is losing it while Carla seems to be picking up steam. Should be a good run to the finish, but I have to agree it's Stefan's competition to lose.

I think Jamie said she liked some of the dishes at the lunch, but she didn't like a couple of others, so not like she totally hated it. As for Stefan, I believe he said he wasn't paying much attention to how each dish was made as he was busy enjoying the food except he remembered the lobster dish the most and had that one figured out the best and that was why he chose it. Hosea said it was the easiest, not sure if Stefan said the same.

ETA: Even though Stefan is arrogant alot of the time and I didn't like him much at first, now he's kinda grown on me as he's funny at times and also despite his big ego, he's back it up practically every single time. He's won the most quickfires and elimination challenges by far and he's only ever been on the chopping block once and that was only because it was mandatory because he lost to Andrea in that Superbowl challenge. And as far as I remember, even his worst dishes were never that awful unlike most of the other chefs who have all made some pretty bad ones.

[MaximDude]

Oh, but you forget! If there were scallops in the later rounds, it would be Top Scallop and Jamie would win! :lol:

Let's hope Stefan (or maybe some will not hope) that he will not burn in the finals like Richard did last season

Yeah, Jamie would definitely win Top Scallop. :cheesygri

As for Stefan, I'm betting he'll be fine in the finals and won't have a braincramp like Richard did. Stefan is really organized and seems to always have his sh$t together and executes his dishes well. The only way I can see him losing is if he makes a really bad menu or if someone else cooks out of their mind and comes up with their best dishes for the finals and beats him.

[bembol]

Don't mean to get off topic...

It was Season Four Chicago, after the second episode my sister pointed this out...

"Winning and elimination decisions were made by the Judges in consultation with producers. Some elimination decisions were discussed with Bravo."

I questioned their decisions on who get eliminated. Especially, after Dale (from Chicago) got voted out over Lisa. We all agreed that Spike worked with Lisa to take him out. I still think at the end, they (Producers) kept her because she causes drama in the Kitchen.

[bembol]

As for last night episode, my brother and I agreed that this is one of the best Elimination challenges ever. I can't believe my brother, who's working to becoming a (Top, LOL) Chef met Eric Ripert.

We both thought it was going to be Leah too (why I posted it ^ ), the past few episodes she just keeps failing and if Radhika didn't take the Front of the House she would've went home. Her giving up at the Quick Fire Challenge was sad.

I love Hosea staring Stefan down after he picked to do the Lobster. LOL It didn't surprise me the comments the judges made on Stefan's skills. The prize he got for winning the elimination was incredible.

I just don't see Stefan losing.

[shannn]

Don't mean to get off topic...

It was Season Four Chicago, after the second episode my sister pointed this out...

"Winning and elimination decisions were made by the Judges in consultation with producers. Some elimination decisions were discussed with Bravo."

I questioned their decisions on who get eliminated. Especially, after Dale (from Chicago) got voted out over Lisa. We all agreed that Spike worked with Lisa to take him out. I still think at the end, they (Producers) kept her because she causes drama in the Kitchen.

+1
I think that may be why Fabio is still here

But I wonder why Leah is still here? Maybe later on more drama arises b/w her and Hosea?
But Jamie brought some "umph" w/ her, because she was the only vocal, confident female chef this season...


But yea, I really disliked how Lisa acted last season...if she won, o m g, I think a lot of people would have been angry

[NDman]

I am going against the grain here. I actually dislike the elimination challenge last night. It speaks of no creativity on their part. It's more of how refine their palette is and how they can resolve a dish. It takes a lot of skills and a lot of pressure for sure. But it doesn't really say too much about them being a chef who is able to really create. It suits for a Quick Fire more than an elimination, IMO

[-=Wraith=-]

I am going against the grain here. I actually dislike the elimination challenge last night. It speaks of no creativity on their part. It's more of how refine their palette is and how they can resolve a dish. It takes a lot of skills and a lot of pressure for sure. But it doesn't really say too much about them being a chef who is able to really create. It suits for a Quick Fire more than an elimination, IMO

they did the exact same thing in season 3 (at Jean-Georges?) except all the chefs cooked the same dish and it was a quick fire.

[kgen]

Say whaaaa!?

Leah totally should've gotten the boot tonight, especially while they were discussing amongst themselves what's worse: someone who knows exactly what mistakes they made, or someone who doesn't really understand the dish.

[shannn]

Say whaaaa!?

Leah totally should've gotten the boot tonight, especially while they were discussing amongst themselves what's worse: someone who knows exactly what mistakes they made, or someone who doesn't really understand the dish.

Yea, I know :mad:

Added to the fact that she gave up on the quickfire (and towards the end of cooking her elimination dish), man...I think they messed up on this elimination

IMO, this was worse than the superbowl elimination...added to the fact that they also eliminated probably the 2nd or 3rd best chef of this competition, o m g

[BD006]

Don't mean to get off topic...

It was Season Four Chicago, after the second episode my sister pointed this out...

"Winning and elimination decisions were made by the Judges in consultation with producers. Some elimination decisions were discussed with Bravo."

I questioned their decisions on who get eliminated. Especially, after Dale (from Chicago) got voted out over Lisa. We all agreed that Spike worked with Lisa to take him out. I still think at the end, they (Producers) kept her because she causes drama in the Kitchen.

Did you watch season two?

It was after that season that I learned producers were a part of the decision making.

Anyways, just finished watching the last episode last night, and am kind of disappointed Jamie went home. I'm wasn't a fan of hers, but thought she was one of the better contestants, maybe a notch below Stefan, and equal to Hosea.

I don't know HOW Leah is still in this competition.

[BD006]

Yea, I know :mad:

Added to the fact that she gave up on the quickfire (and towards the end of cooking her elimination dish), man...I think they messed up on this elimination

IMO, this was worse than the superbowl elimination...added to the fact that they also eliminated probably the 2nd or 3rd best chef of this competition, o m g

+1 with everything you said

[Brandon]

I am going against the grain here. I actually dislike the elimination challenge last night. It speaks of no creativity on their part. It's more of how refine their palette is and how they can resolve a dish. It takes a lot of skills and a lot of pressure for sure. But it doesn't really say too much about them being a chef who is able to really create. It suits for a Quick Fire more than an elimination, IMO

It's not creative, but it shows how well a chef can create a dish that they have in their mind. They can have good creativity, but if they can't recreate their vision into reality then it doesn't matter. It's about consistently being able to make a dish.

Have you ever gone to a restaurant and had something you really like, but the next time it doesn't taste the same? It's a practical skill they need to have as chefs (which Jamie sucked at big time).

It seems as if Jamie has a chip on her shoulders. Maybe she got razzed on a lot because she's a lesbian. She didn't really get the concept of Ripert's dishes (especially since she had trouble in the first test preparation of the dish... she didn't make it on time... and she skewed the final dish too). You can have your own style, but when all the other chefs were saying how good the food was in cut scenes (like Hosea and Stefan, the strongest competitors), then I mean who are you going to side with?

Maybe Jamie was on her time of month and thus b**chy and not cooperating with anyone. The producers used their influence to kick her off because they didn't like her whiny comments that would last most of the rest of the season.

[shannn]

It's not creative, but it shows how well a chef can create a dish that they have in their mind. They can have good creativity, but if they can't recreate their vision into reality then it doesn't matter. It's about consistently being able to make a dish.

Have you ever gone to a restaurant and had something you really like, but the next time it doesn't taste the same? It's a practical skill they need to have as chefs (which Jamie sucked at big time).

It seems as if Jamie has a chip on her shoulders. Maybe she got razzed on a lot because she's a lesbian. She didn't really get the concept of Ripert's dishes (especially since she had trouble in the first test preparation of the dish... she didn't make it on time... and she skewed the final dish too). You can have your own style, but when all the other chefs were saying how good the food was in cut scenes (like Hosea and Stefan, the strongest competitors), then I mean who are you going to side with?

Maybe Jamie was on her time of month and thus b**chy and not cooperating with anyone. The producers used their influence to kick her off because they didn't like her whiny comments that would last most of the rest of the season.

True

Maybe Eric didn't like her dissing up his foods so he had her kicked, lol

But regardless of her attitude, you can't deny her ability (as shown in the previous eliminations)...still think it is too bad she is going home...it would have at least been interesting to see how Stefan's attraction toward her shaped the next couple episodes if she stuck around lol

[victory01]

True

Maybe Eric didn't like her dissing up his foods so he had her kicked, lol

But regardless of her attitude, you can't deny her ability (as shown in the previous eliminations)...still think it is too bad she is going home...it would have at least been interesting to see how Stefan's attraction toward her shaped the next couple episodes if she stuck around lol

I duno about that. She was sitting on Fabio's lap in the waiting room before elimination.

[victory01]

Great episode! Everything unfolded like it should have.

Padma looked SMOKING HOT!!!! I kept willing the camera on her at elimination.

[shannn]

Great episode! Everything unfolded like it should have.

Padma looked SMOKING HOT!!!! I kept willing the camera on her at elimination.

Episode was pretty good

(white = spoilers below)
Wow, so Leah is finally gone...but I dunno...I actually felt like..she deserved to stay this episode...Stefan should have been eliminated, lol (IMO)
And wow, Carla used to be a model? That is surprising
Good win for Fabio...oh man, it was disgusting seeing his broken finger...he's a brave star for doing so well w/ his injury!
Padma....drool, lol, smoking

Final 4!

[bembol]

First, Padma was smoking hot!!!! :drool:

Congrats to Fabio for keeping his focus after that incident with his finger. Seeing the preview last week I thought he would have to leave Top Chef due to injury.

Also, Carla is on a roll and she looks to be a threat. Hosea and Stefan are both loosing focus because they keep going at it and seems to just argue on who's the best.

Don't mean to get off topic...

It was Season Four Chicago, after the second episode my sister pointed this out...

"Winning and elimination decisions were made by the Judges in consultation with producers. Some elimination decisions were discussed with Bravo."


I quoted this ^ again because I was praying for Producers to save him and I think at the end they did. Honestly, we (my Brother, Sister and I) think Stefan SHOULD'VE went home for OVER COOKING his Protein. As my brother said, there's just no excuse for it.

Stefan is amazing and IMO the Top Chef but he's just too cocky and he seems to focus on Hosea too much.

As for Leah, I'm thankful she slipped. Honestly, she kept falling and I have to say she got lucky several times that she didn't go home.

[shannn]

I quoted this ^ again because I was praying for Producers to save him and I think at the end they did. Honestly, we (my Brother, Sister and I) think Stefan SHOULD'VE went home for OVER COOKING his Protein. As my brother said, there's just no excuse for it.

Stefan is amazing and IMO the Top Chef but he's just too cocky and he seems to focus on Hosea too much.

As for Leah, I'm thankful she slipped. Honestly, she kept falling and I have to say she got lucky several times that she didn't go home.

+1

Stefan is soooo cokcy, esp when he was talking about how Hosea was not worthy to be a chef...o m g, haha, cocky to the max

But I am happy Leah was gone...she deserved to stay this time, but not the last 3 weeks...But wow, I reallly wonder who will be going nexxt week

I mean, Stefan is pretty much guaranteed to have good food, Fabio has been on a roll as has Carla...but Hosea has been stumbling lately...but again, he has the potential to pull off great food

Hmmmmmmmmmm, can't wait for next week!

Hard to believe all this was recorded in about a month, it must be stressful on these chefs!

[victory01]

First, Padma was smoking hot!!!! :drool:

Congrats to Fabio for keeping his focus after that incident with his finger. Seeing the preview last week I thought he would have to leave Top Chef due to injury.

Also, Carla is on a roll and she looks to be a threat. Hosea and Stefan are both loosing focus because they keep going at it and seems to just argue on who's the best.



I quoted this ^ again because I was praying for Producers to save him and I think at the end they did. Honestly, we (my Brother, Sister and I) think Stefan SHOULD'VE went home for OVER COOKING his Protein. As my brother said, there's just no excuse for it.

Stefan is amazing and IMO the Top Chef but he's just too cocky and he seems to focus on Hosea too much.

As for Leah, I'm thankful she slipped. Honestly, she kept falling and I have to say she got lucky several times that she didn't go home.

I agree, but it's a battle between judging a single challenge versus judging a chefs total performance. Some times a track record comes into play when everyone messes up.

[MaximDude]

No surprise that Leah is gone, as everyone else left is stronger overall. What was surprising was that Carla was a MODEL??? Really now?? :confused: Maybe she meant she was a hand model or something because I can't fathom it being anything else. Also I think Leah looks pretty good with her hair down. :D

Of the chefs remaining, despite his misstep this episode, I still think Stefan is the odds on to win it all. But it seems to be much closer now that Carla and Fabio have upped their game abit and Hosea still has good skills to compete. But again its Stefan's to take.

Also Fabio shaving his hair into a mohawk? WTF? :lol:

[Brandon]

I'm guessing the finale will be Hosea, Stefan and Carla.

I still think my final 3 is right. I HOPE Fabio makes it instead of Carla.

Stefan reminds me of Hung. They both backed up their cockiness with a bunch of wins and the few times they screwed up were funny (since they were cocky about it).

[kgen]

No surprise that Leah is gone, as everyone else left is stronger overall. What was surprising was that Carla was a MODEL??? Really now?? :confused: Maybe she meant she was a hand model or something because I can't fathom it being anything else. Also I think Leah looks pretty good with her hair down. :D

Of the chefs remaining, despite his misstep this episode, I still think Stefan is the odds on to win it all. But it seems to be much closer now that Carla and Fabio have upped their game abit and Hosea still has good skills to compete. But again its Stefan's to take.

Also Fabio shaving his hair into a mohawk? WTF? :lol:

I don't know, a lot of the runway models aren't exactly super hot... but they do fit the whole model image (tall, skinny).

It's good to see stefan get lose after watching him poke fun at fabio's "airplane food".

[blarg]

Padma is so hot.

[bembol]

^ Yes, that's been covered. j/k LOL Why can't we get Bravo in HD!

I agree, but it's a battle between judging a single challenge versus judging a chefs total performance. Some times a track record comes into play when everyone messes up.

That's the point with Top Chef, their past challenges doesn't mean anything.

As Fabio said, it doesn't make a difference whether you win 10 challenges or none, you screw up you are gone.

[NDman]

Just finished watching from the DVR. Best quote of the entire series:

"Hospital!? I'll chop it off; put it on a flat top; sear it and stop the bleeding!". This guy is quite something!

Wife and I were talking about the results and both thought that the producer must have saved Stefan from the fall. Afterall, who doesn't want to see the continuous feuding between Hosea and Stefan? Getting rid one of them right now just won't do them any good. And they played it out that way for the semi-final preview at the end of the episode too. It looked quite obvious Leah got shafted strictly by the results.

That said though, she deserved to go at least 1-2 episodes ago, if not earlier. No problem with her gone there

EDIT: And there they were playing funky music again when they cut to Carla's commentary during the Quick Fire. Hilarious stuff

[MaximDude]

Just finished watching from the DVR. Best quote of the entire series:

"Hospital!? I'll chop it off; put it on a flat top; sear it and stop the bleeding!". This guy is quite something!

Wife and I were talking about the results and both thought that the producer must have saved Stefan from the fall. Afterall, who doesn't want to see the continuous feuding between Hosea and Stefan? Getting rid one of them right now just won't do them any good. And they played it out that way for the semi-final preview at the end of the episode too. It looked quite obvious Leah got shafted strictly by the results.

That said though, she deserved to go at least 1-2 episodes ago, if not earlier. No problem with her gone there

EDIT: And there they were playing funky music again when they cut to Carla's commentary during the Quick Fire. Hilarious stuff

I think on one of the judges blogs he wrote that he thought that Hosea and Leah's dishes were both worse than Stefan's. For Stefan, he only overcooked the fish, but got the sauce right. What did Leah do right for her dish? I don't think any judges were blown away by her dish and she got her sauce totally wrong. So even if you throw out past performances, Leah deserved to go more since her dish was executed the least best.

Also still can't believe that Carla was a model!?!?!! I still maintain she did hand modelling. :lol:

[Brandon]

Wife and I were talking about the results and both thought that the producer must have saved Stefan from the fall. Afterall, who doesn't want to see the continuous feuding between Hosea and Stefan? Getting rid one of them right now just won't do them any good. And they played it out that way for the semi-final preview at the end of the episode too. It looked quite obvious Leah got shafted strictly by the results.

Holandaise sauce is what makes eggs benedict. Leah screwed it up, plus the chef from Sweden (I think) said that the textures were all wrong for the dish.

Stefan's dish had the right flavour, but the execution wasn't good (salmon overcooked and 2 types of spinach that really wasn't discernable).

So do you pick the person who executed badly or the person who didn't get the concept of the dish correctly? Based on other elimination rounds, they tend to pick the person who executed badly (except when execution was horrible).

[NDman]

I am happy to see Leah go, don't get me wrong. I think it's the way the cut to the comments from the judges that created that illusion. The spinach from Stefan's dish also seemed to be a mis-step. There was obviously a split of opinions among the panel of the tasters last night, which is expected when you have a big crowd, with some young and some old.

The problem with Leah's Egg Benedict was probably that, like many had already said, it didn't stand out. It as nothing too special that could win the judges over.

Carla's presence is really growing on me. Wife and I were shocked too when she said she used to be a model. She definitely has the height! I really hope Bravo would recruit both Carla and Fabio to the Top Chef tour. Then maybe I'll get to meet them if they ever go on tour to the Bay Area again (met Stefanie Izzard and Bryan Scott last year here) :)

[shannn]

All I have to say is, Fabio FTW!
Finals will probably be Stefan, Fabio, and either Hosea or Carla
Carla is coming on strong...Hosea has made a few missteps the past 2 challenges...so we will see

If you look at this contestant chart on here (via Wikipedia) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Chef_(season_5)), Stefan has the most wins, and Stefan and Fabio are tied for the most times being in the Top 3...Carla is a closely behind, but Hosea actually has the least top 3's...

Oh yea, BTW, I know Top Chef is on ITunes, but are there any places to watch it for free? ;) Like any websites or antyhing?
I missed a few of the past season's episodes, and would like to see those

[NDman]

Oh yea, BTW, I know Top Chef is on ITunes, but are there any places to watch it for free? ;) Like any websites or antyhing?
I missed a few of the past season's episodes, and would like to see those

BT would be your best bet. Not that I know anything about it... :cheesygri

[shannn]

BT would be your best bet. Not that I know anything about it... :cheesygri

Ahhhh, I figured :lol:
Was hoping there would be a website or something...but, as long as I get to watch it, lol

[squall458]

What time and day is this show on Food network? Wednesdays?

[victory01]

What time and day is this show on Food network? Wednesdays?

Wednesday nights at 10pm and again at 2am

Then again on Saturdays at around 3pm.

[shannn]

Wednesday nights at 10pm and again at 2am

Then again on Saturdays at around 3pm.

Oh, nice, I never knew Food Network Canada showed it at the same time as Bravo TV America

I wonder why Bravo Canada doesn't show Bravo American shows, like Top Chef

[victory01]

Oh, nice, I never knew Food Network Canada showed it at the same time as Bravo TV America

I wonder why Bravo Canada doesn't show Bravo American shows, like Top Chef

I noticed! When I was in Dominican Republic last month I noticed a lot of shows on the American channels like Tool Academy that do not show in Canada. They all promote to catch full episodes on the website. I come home and they don't even allow me to see them online because I'm from Canada. Weird.

[squall458]

Wednesday nights at 10pm and again at 2am

Then again on Saturdays at around 3pm.

Thank you!!!

[shannn]

Wowzerz

Just watched a commercial about the first part of hte finale

Guest judge: Emeril Lagasse
--> Double Elimination

Wow, who will it be in the finals:

Stefan vs. ____________________

For some strange reason, I think it may be Stefan vs. Hosea b/c of their rivalry...it'll be like Ilan vs. Marcel from season 2...rivalry to the max!

But I really hope it is Carla vs. Fabio

[bembol]

*SPOILER* Couldn't resist posting. :twisted:











I don't know why but tonight's episode started off with a twist. This season is my favorite so I was happy to see the last three (Leah, Jamie & Jeff) that got Eliminated got a second chance with a Quick Fire challenge.

I knew Jeff would win it, so this makes the Finale even more interesting.

[shannn]

Total spoiler alert:

I'm kinda bummed to see Fabio go home :( But in this episode I think they made the right call (it was also nice to see Gail back! No more Toby, finally!)

Kinda guessed that Jeff would win the quickfire then lose later...he is a great chef, and I always knew he'd make it to the finale, lol, just never expected it in this way....but still, it was great seeing him not complicate things tonight, he should have done that the entire season!

Good to see Carla win! She's on a real hot streak (kinda like Richard from last season, eh? lol, and we know how that turned out)

But I think the comments they gave Stefan will give him the kick in the nuts he needs to cook some good food for the finale! Still think it is Stefan's to lose, he just gotta lose some of his cocky attitude

IMO, this was the best episode this season by far, although Fabio was obviously disadvantaged by the fact that the American chefs had obvious southern/creyole cooking exp....still, can't wait for the final!

[victory01]

^ +1

Also....Padma was stunning tonight! When I saw her walk down those stairs I was like, "hell yeah!". Amazing dress.

Favorite quotes....

"The current car I have is..........poop."
"We almost had the first semi final with no mo-hawks until Fabio ****ed it up! Yeah, thanks fabio."

[shannn]

Padma looked pretty nice, but I think her lack of a refined palate showed in this episode...she loved the dish of Fabio's that everyone was hating on...which she later flip flopped and started to hate on it too, lol

Man, gonna miss Fabio's character :lol: Ahhh well, we got the rivalry b/w Hosea and Stefan to look forward to
I hope Fabio at least wins fan favorite top chef...he sounds like he needs that $10K!

[bembol]

What is Stefan doing?!?!? I'm not sure if he did it before but taking a smoke break during the Elimination Challenge crazy, I was just shaking my head. But he made it like I thought he would because of the Hosea vs Stefan rivalry. So I wasn't surprised that Hosea is in the finale.

Jeff, I knew was strong if he could slow down and really focus which he did but it was a tough challenge that he had win the Elimination. I would've love it if he won and I really thought he had it base of the Judge's comments. But Carla stepped up and again surprised me. I love her and the attitude but I'm not a fan.

As for Fabio, it's too bad he got eliminated. Southern Cooking wasn't his style/strength so I wasn't surprised he was in the bottom with Stefan.

BTW, I love the Toyota Venza. Congrats, to Carla.

[squall458]

Padma was smoking hot in that pinkish red dress in the episode where Leah got booted. Just the way it flowed over her body. Gorgeous.

[MaximDude]

I knew Carla was going to win as soon as the judges said they loved her dishes during the party. While watching the chefs prepare their food if I had the choice, the oyster stew was the one I wanted to try the most and when the judges raved about it, you knew she had it in the bag.

As for Stefan, you had to know he wasn't going anywhere. Even though his dishes weren't awesome that episode, he still did alright and is still better and more consistent than Fabio. Not totally sure I like eliminated chefs coming back with another chance to get to the finals though. It would really suck if Jeff had won and two other chefs had to leave considering they made it that far fair and square only to be kicked off by someone who was already gone from the show.

I still give Stefan the edge in winning, but Carla has REALLY stepped it up and Hosea is still decent. Could be a pretty good finals. Also I liked Carla's hair when she was in New Orleans more than I liked her hair the whole season. :lol:

[kgen]

Yeah, I don't think Fabio's as good as the final three. I'm also _really_ surprised at how well Carla is doing in the last few episodes. It seems like everyone is still underestimating her while she silently pulls out the big ones.

I don't see stefan winning at this point unless the other two make major mistakes -- he just doesn't seem like a guy you'd want as a 'Top Chef', especially with his attitude.

[dekay]

I don't see stefan winning at this point unless the other two make major mistakes -- he just doesn't seem like a guy you'd want as a 'Top Chef', especially with his attitude.

Stephan was what made the show good this season. And I don't mind his attitude at all cause he has the skills to back it up. He's probably won the most quickfire+elimination challenges in the history of the show.

[NDman]

Stephan was what made the show good this season. And I don't mind his attitude at all cause he has the skills to back it up. He's probably won the most quickfire+elimination challenges in the history of the show.

Stefan has slowly turned into Lisa of last season, which like you said made for great TV. Every show needs a villain, especially this kind of semi-reality show. I do think he needs to wake up from this and deflate his big head a little in order for him to win. He didn't respond to the reality check from last week (though it seemed like it has been a while since they left NY) and continued his own way that led to a failure.

Too bad for Fabio though. Would have been a feel good story had he won the money to help his sick mother back home. But he was clearly the weakest among the final 4, not counting Jeff

Now that Fabio is gone, I am definitely rooting for Carla. "It's the loooooove thing!"

[shannn]

Stefan has slowly turned into Lisa of last season, which like you said made for great TV. Every show needs a villain, especially this kind of semi-reality show. I do think he needs to wake up from this and deflate his big head a little in order for him to win. He didn't respond to the reality check from last week (though it seemed like it has been a while since they left NY) and continued his own way that led to a failure.

Really? I know I reallllllly disliked Lisa b/c of her attitude, but I dunno...I actually find Stefan kind of funny b/c of his cockiness
And Stefan is an excellent chef and has been able to show it all season in Top Chef...Lisa didn't really bring it (IMO) until the finals

Even though Stefan has stumbled a lot...in the final, the cooks will be cooking what they want to cook w/ no restrictions (besides the ingredients)...I think what screwed Stefan in those other challenges were the restrictions...so, I think we should see some good stuff from him

Too bad for Fabio though. Would have been a feel good story had he won the money to help his sick mother back home. But he was clearly the weakest among the final 4, not counting Jeff

I know! He drives a piece of poop, and his mom is sick...I honestly hope he wins the $10K for being the viewer's favorite chef
And I'm sure his restaurant is probably gaining popularity after the show

Now that Fabio is gone, I am definitely rooting for Carla. "It's the loooooove thing!"

:lol:
I love Carla's style and how she is now sticking to what she believes in (now that she has confidence!)

But I still think this is Stefan's competition

Stephan was what made the show good this season. And I don't mind his attitude at all cause he has the skills to back it up. He's probably won the most quickfire+elimination challenges in the history of the show.

Totally agree

[MaximDude]

Congrats to Hosea winning I guess. What a SUPER short celebration. Some handshakes, a few hugs and that's about it.

Stefan, man you messed up on the appetizer. Freezing the fish was your downfall. The dessert to me didn't look too bad, but it seems all the judges didn't think it was all that great. Hosea cooked his best meal and stayed with his strengths instead of trying to make a dessert and as a result he wins.

As for Carla, should have just stuck to your original menu instead of listening to Casey, and you choked abit too. Messed up your main course and then you forget about the souffle. If you stuck to your guns and cooked what you planned to cook, you would have been in the running. Oh well.

[blarg]

Blah Hosea, wanted Stefan to win.

Padma was hot as usual and Gail too...she had a really nice uhhhh dress...

[MaximDude]

Blah Hosea, wanted Stefan to win.

Padma was hot as usual and Gail too...she had a really nice uhhhh dress...

Yeah I was just going to add. Gail!! :-0 :-0 Her chest was pretty damn distracting the whole show! lol But I'm so glad she had a kid! :lol:

[victory01]

It sucks that Carla didn't stick to her original plan. There will always be a 'what if' now.
I understand that Stephan likes his meals to end in a dessert but he had to understand that it was the last thing everyone was going to taste. I did like how he handled the croc though.

Congrats to Hosea. I like how they overkilled the shot of Leah giving him a hug, lol.

And as usual...Padma was smoking! Gail was gunning tonight too, wow.

[bembol]

*sigh* I really thought Stefan had it! I guess when his best friend Fabio, said that Hosea ended it much stronger, you know he came up short.

I really don't understand why Tom, Gale and Padma kept ignoring Stefan took a chance, it's not like the Desert was ****. The other Judges like Toby Young, Hubert Keller and Tory McPhail loved that Stefan had balls/took that risk.

I guess he could've pulled off something stronger, as he said at the end but this is why I love and consider Stefan THE Top Chef, he doesn't take the easy road. His only downfall was the First Course, freezing the Halibut & Salmon Carpaccio.

Hosea made everything difficult for Stefan by taking all the Ingredients, giving him Alligator and he pulled through.

This is the problem with the Finale, they cannot just base their decision on tonight's menu, any Chef can win if they have Luck on their side like with Hosea or Fail because of missteps like with Carla. They need to consider Past Challenges.

[dekay]

^
For the same token, they all made the finals for a reason. So if they're considered "equals", then they should be judged on the current challenge.

Anyhow, quite dissapointed that Hosea won. Not sure what i missed in the first 10 minutes, but they shouldn't have done that cake thing where the lucky person can pick ingredients for other ppl. Just let them cook their own food or require each person use the same ingredient. Biggest let down in Top Chef thus far; even worst than Richard's loss in the finals.

[NDman]

I actually felt a little bad for Stefan. And he actually got some emotion going on too.

Too bad Carla was doomed by herself for not sticking to her way. It was a tough way to go.

Is it just me or anyone found the finale lacked any sorts of climax? It was so blah. No drama, what-so-ever.

Next week's reunion looks pretty interesting, and Hosea/Leah got asked the million-dollar question. :cheesygri

[dekay]

imo part 1 of the finale was better than the final episode.

[shannn]

Wow, for the second straight season, the top chef of the competition was not awarded the title of Top Chef....dissapointing for sure
If it keeps going on like this, people should just strive for second and then win at the finals, lol

And it is hte first year that the winner of hte first elimination was not winner overall.

Honestly, I really think they have to start making dessert's mandatory, because really...if you are experiencing fine dining at any restaurant ANYWHERE, there will always be a dessert at the end. It is not like Stefan's dessert was crap either...I mean, last season, Stephanie had a simple pound cake...Stefan deserved to be top chef no doubt about it...But I think it was his capaccio dish taht killed him...if he served something else (like a salad), IMO, he would have won


And I realllllly wish that the producers will make the finals only 2 people...I was honeslty hoping this season would go back to this way (since they said it would be a double elimination, but they brought Jeff back)...it honestly makes the decision making better IMO


Also, man, I feel for Carla, her lack of confidence bit her in this final. It was sad too, because she gained all that momentum and confidence as the show progressed, only to lose the competition b/c of her lack of ability to stand for what she believed in - cooking dishes that were simple and to HER liking

Man....pretty dissapointing overall...I think that if Fabio, Jeff or Jamie were in the finals, they would have taken it because they were the ones that succeeded the most when there were no restrictions in the competition.

But regardless, Hosea did pull off impressive dishes during the finale. Guess that means he'll be opening up his own restaurant soon.

I would relaly like to see a competition w/ all the Top Chefs (Harold, Ilan, Hung, Stephanie and Hosea)...that would be awesome

---------

So, is anyone going to try out for Season 6? :lol: Wonder where it will take place...and I wonder if Food Network Canada will try to create a Top Chef Canada, lol

I think they have some auditions in New York City and Boston in the next couple of weeks.
I wish I could drop by, lol, and try out...alwyas loved to cook

[slowtyper]

This was such a crappy finale. It should be a 7 course meal with mandatory dessert and unlimited prep time with no restrictions. What is this BS?

[NDman]

So, is anyone going to try out for Season 6? :lol: Wonder where it will take place...and I wonder if Food Network Canada will try to create a Top Chef Canada, lol

I think they have some auditions in New York City and Boston in the next couple of weeks.
I wish I could drop by, lol, and try out...alwyas loved to cook

It is practically by invitation only (there might be a nomination/application part) from what I heard from Ryan Scott and Stephanie Izzard. On the similar note, I think they should just scrap the location name altogether. The location is completely irrelevant. All the chefs are invited from all over the country to compete at one central location that has no bearing on where the chefs were based in.

I also think a dessert should be mandatory for an open challenge like this one

[victory01]

This was such a crappy finale. It should be a 7 course meal with mandatory dessert and unlimited prep time with no restrictions. What is this BS?

Totally agree! I duno about unlimited but all day to prepare for sure. The 'find the doll in the cake' was so stupid! That could make or break a meal and they left the entire thing up to chance. Basically make it to top 3 and flip a coin on who gets croc...yay.

I thought Carla would keep the ball rolling with southern food but turned to French. I also thought she would make that pastry for dessert that the judges were raving about all season.

Good luck to Fabio for fan fav.

[sPiKyAZN]

It's pretty disappointing to see Hosea win...if I had to choose between a meal from Hosea and a meal from Stefan I would pick Stefan's meal any day. Throughout the whole competition Hosea never really excited me with any of my dishes. Although Stefan is really cocky he has the skills to back it up. Maybe the producers didn't want the "villain" to win? haha.

This is the first season of Top Chef for me and I am so happy I found it. These chefs are a million times more talented than the garbage on Hells Kitchen.

[bembol]

Wow, for the second straight season, the top chef of the competition was not awarded the title of Top Chef....dissapointing for sure
If it keeps going on like this, people should just strive for second and then win at the finals, lol

And it is hte first year that the winner of hte first elimination was not winner overall.

Honestly, I really think they have to start making dessert's mandatory, because really...if you are experiencing fine dining at any restaurant ANYWHERE, there will always be a dessert at the end. It is not like Stefan's dessert was crap either...I mean, last season, Stephanie had a simple pound cake...Stefan deserved to be top chef no doubt about it...But I think it was his capaccio dish taht killed him...if he served something else (like a salad), IMO, he would have won

+1 as I said earlier though none of my brother & sister don't agree.

And I realllllly wish that the producers will make the finals only 2 people...I was honeslty hoping this season would go back to this way (since they said it would be a double elimination, but they brought Jeff back)...it honestly makes the decision making better IMO


Also, man, I feel for Carla, her lack of confidence bit her in this final. It was sad too, because she gained all that momentum and confidence as the show progressed, only to lose the competition b/c of her lack of ability to stand for what she believed in - cooking dishes that were simple and to HER liking

Man....pretty dissapointing overall...I think that if Fabio, Jeff or Jamie were in the finals, they would have taken it because they were the ones that succeeded the most when there were no restrictions in the competition.

But regardless, Hosea did pull off impressive dishes during the finale. Guess that means he'll be opening up his own restaurant soon.

I just read on EW, he is. Also, both Leah & Hosea are Single and remain good friends. LOL


I would relaly like to see a competition w/ all the Top Chefs (Harold, Ilan, Hung, Stephanie and Hosea)...that would be awesome

Yes, this would be sick!!! Out of these "Top Chef", I think Hung will kill them all. LOL

---------

So, is anyone going to try out for Season 6? :lol: Wonder where it will take place...and I wonder if Food Network Canada will try to create a Top Chef Canada, lol

I hope NOT, I really can't stand when Canada makes their Version (Canadian Idol. I can't even think of the others. No, I do not watch American Idol. LOL

I think they have some auditions in New York City and Boston in the next couple of weeks.
I wish I could drop by, lol, and try out...alwyas loved to cook.

I would like to see Boston too.

:twisted:

[NDman]

And speaking of Food Network cross-over, did anyone watch the Iron Chef America this past Sunday - Amanda Freitag vs Flay? Arianne was one of Freitag's sous chef. And guess what dish she was in-charge of making? Lamb!

[bembol]

Who saw the Reunion last night?

I knew Fabio would win the Fan favorite/$10,000 prize.

Stefan is my favorite and his segment on the Women of Top Chef, specifically on Jamie, knowing that she's a lesbian but still want her was so funny and seeing Padma again at the end of it with her in that jaw-dropping dress and Stefan's reaction was gold! LMAO

I didn't know there was a Birthday Curse with Eugene, Radhika and Leah getting voted off on their day. There was also a unseen footage of Jamie and Leah getting wasted since they knew they were safe and lost it when they appeared in front of the judges. :twisted: :cheesygri

[shannn]

Who saw the Reunion last night?

I knew Fabio would win the Fan favorite/$10,000 prize.

Stefan is my favorite and his segment on the Women of Top Chef, specifically on Jamie, knowing that she's a lesbian but still want her was so funny and seeing Padma again at the end of it with her in that jaw-dropping dress and Stefan's reaction was gold! LMAO

I didn't know there was a Birthday Curse with Eugene, Radhika and Leah getting voted off on their day. There was also a unseen footage of Jamie and Leah getting wasted since they knew they were safe and lost it when they appeared in front of the judges. :twisted: :cheesygri

LOL
This was one of the more memorable reunions IMO
The b-day thing was freaaaakkky, and Jeff also put his foot in his mouth by talking ish about Tom's food, lol

Seeing Jamie and Leah wasted was hilarious, haha

And great for Fabio, he really deserved it.
Carla won a car, Fabio won money, and Stefan got his own clothing line going, and of course Hosea is top chef... so all the final 4 got something at least, :lol:

-----

But overall, I felt like this season was lacking...
It just didn't have that "oomph" that Season 2 and 3 had, which are still the best ones IMO
I mean, no rivalry will beat Ilan and Marcel's (the attempt this season sucked b/c IMO, Hosea wasn't really up to it b/c his skills were kind of lacking)
No one will ever be as cocky as Hung (although Stefan was close, but he couldn't close it out by winning Top Chef)
And no one will ever be as hot as Casey :twisted:

And also, I mean...nothing that memorable really happened...and the decision making judge wise was...debatable at best


Get rid of Toby Young! And bring on Season 6!
For this year's holiday special, I want to see an all out battle with Harold vs. Ilan vs. Hung vs. Stephanie vs. Hosea

Hung is still my favourite, haha, and would probably win out in that challenge
Check out these clips, lol, no chef this season brought that style and swagger he has to the table, lol:
Chicken Time (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnMiyBLhonE)
Smurf Villiage (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Zh4zfEEuPQ)

----------

But yea, like you said earlier too,
I hate Canadian spin offs of good American shows
I hope that there will never be a Top Chef Canada, because, seriously...it would just suck, lol

But on the other hand, I would love for Top Chef to come to Toronto or something, but will most likely NEVER happen...maybe Vancouver though

[NDman]

It had to be between Fabio and Carla for the Fan Favourite (just my guess) and I would think Fabio is the run-away winner. I think it was an easy choice.

The footage showing Leah and Jamie drunk was awesome. The judges panel couldn't do a thing about it but to laugh with them. Priceless!

[bembol]

To Bravo, can we please get a REAL All-Stars challenge! Here's my Top 12...

Hung
Blase
Stefan
Sam
Stephanie
Lee Anne
Jeff
Fabio
Trey
Cliff
Casey
Dale

The last two are not certain. I'm at work and can't remember all of them

Also, where are the Blu-rays Disc?!?! I've seen one episode on High-Def and wish Bravo would release them. I don't care if they start with this season.

[NDman]

To Bravo, can we please get a REAL All-Stars challenge! Here's my Top 12...


I think I read that this is the last season of Top Chef on Bravo. Some other station will carry the show but I can't remember which

[shannn]

I think I read that this is the last season of Top Chef on Bravo. Some other station will carry the show but I can't remember which

I think that was with Project Runway (Magical Elves produces both shows, and they moved Project Runway)

To Bravo, can we please get a REAL All-Stars challenge! Here's my Top 12...

Hung
Blase
Stefan
Sam
Stephanie
Lee Anne
Jeff
Fabio
Trey
Cliff
Casey
Dale

The last two are not certain. I'm at work and can't remember all of them

Also, where are the Blu-rays Disc?!?! I've seen one episode on High-Def and wish Bravo would release them. I don't care if they start with this season.

I think Bravo is only gonna be releasing them on ITunes :cry:
I think if they do an all-stars episode, they gotta pull out the top 3 from each season :cheesygri

Season 1:
Harold
Dave
Lee Anne (I realllly hated Tiffanie, man, wayyy worse than Marcel)

Season 2:
Sam
Ilan (what a joker :lol: )
Elia / Marcel / Cliff (both can cook, both are great, Marcel not so much on the attitude, lol)

Season 3:
Hung
Casey (honestly, Hot Chef, haha)
Dale

Season 4:
Richard
Stephanie
Dale (think he left wayy too early)

Season 5:
Fabio
Stefan
Carla (yea...didn't like Hosea at all, lol)

That would be great!

But I also think that once Season 6 is over, they will have an all out battle b/w the 6 winners...w/ Hung on top, lol, the Top TOP Chef

[NDman]

I think that was with Project Runway (Magical Elves produces both shows, and they moved Project Runway)

I stand corrected if that's the case

[thelefteyeguy]

WOW....reunion show was pure gold...esp the drunk part :cheesygri

[shannn]

Bump, I changed the thread topic and OP

Top Chef Masters starting this Thursday, should be interesting.
I wonder how these world famous chefs will take to the critiques they will be recieving? :lol:
Should be entertaining.

Starts Thursday, June 10 @ 10pm

[bembol]

Thanks for the update. So season six doesn't start until October. :(

I will watch the Masters, it should be interesting.

[Brandon]

Bump, I changed the thread topic and OP

Top Chef Masters starting this Thursday, should be interesting.
I wonder how these world famous chefs will take to the critiques they will be recieving? :lol:
Should be entertaining.

Starts Thursday, June 10 @ 10pm

Wikipedia entry for Top Chef Masters:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Chef_Masters

I haven't heard of most of the chefs participating, but there are some I remember from appearances on Iron Chef America.

[PredatoR_]

Will masters be on bravo canada? I didn't see it in the schedule on their website unless I missed it or something :confused:

[shannn]

Will masters be on bravo canada? I didn't see it in the schedule on their website unless I missed it or something :confused:

I believe it will be on Food Network Canada (like how Top Chef was...but I'm not 100% on this)
Otherwise, you can always torrent the show

[shannn]

Wikipedia entry for Top Chef Masters:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Chef_Masters

I haven't heard of most of the chefs participating, but there are some I remember from appearances on Iron Chef America.

Yup, all there on the original post (or least it should be lol) :cheesygri

I've seen some commercials for it, it is pretty jokes. One chef was upset and in his french accent said, "don't tell me how to cook" :lol:

[Brandon]

Yup, all there on the original post (or least it should be lol) :cheesygri

Ooops, didn't read the first post... just went to the recent ones. I wonder how long some of the 'bigger' celebrity chefs will last.

[shannn]

So...

Anyone else watch it tonight?

It was interesting. I like the concept. It reminds me of...Iron Chef and Top Chef combined.

But...Kelly Choi << Padma :cry: ... but still better than the very first host.



I wish they'd set up a similar type of show like this for all the Top Chef winners.
Hung >> all other Top Chefs :cheesygri

[ebrian]

What channel are you watching it on and what time? I didn't see it in the schedule.

[shannn]

Oh...what the, they aren't even showing this on Food Network.

I guess Food Network Canada is only showing the main series.

I am watching this on American Bravo
I guess the only way to watch it is through torrents :|

[Brandon]

I guess the only way to watch it is through torrents :|

Can't find it... anybody having any luck?

[Brandon]

I just saw it last night. I like the regular Top Chef more. You get to learn more about the chefs as people with that show, but with Masters it's not the same. I wonder if the judges hold back their comments on the professional chefs. I guess I'm just used to seeing chefs get ripped by the judges on the original series.

I'll continue watching the series as it's still pretty good.

[shannn]

I just saw it last night. I like the regular Top Chef more. You get to learn more about the chefs as people with that show, but with Masters it's not the same. I wonder if the judges hold back their comments on the professional chefs. I guess I'm just used to seeing chefs get ripped by the judges on the original series.

I'll continue watching the series as it's still pretty good.

I agree
Their comments seemed toned down (considering the scores the chefs were getting), but watching these chefs do these things is a little funny. :cheesygri

[tyrrell]

Bumping this back to the top as the new season has started.

My early prediction:

The blond girl who won the first quickfire challenge, can't remember her name.

I like having the 2 brothers on the show, should make for good tv.

[bembol]

The Volt brothers and Kevin are my favorites.

I can remember his name but he's friends with the older brother. I'm not liking his cockyness/attitude, I can't wait to see him go.

[victory01]

I like that blonde chick too, Jen i think her name is. But for the sake of good tv i think it's gonna end up coming down to a brother vs brother finale.

[bembol]

Great episode tonight because my top picks did very well. Seeing the Volt Brothers win each challenge was great.

I wasn't surprised when the Women lost the Immunity Challenge, unlike the previous season I don't even have a favorite and too be honest none of them are hot/have the personality. :twisted:

[somemale]

Most talented group yet....

[victory01]

Most talented group yet....

Agree 100%. Just finished watching ep.4, wow....a lot of talent here. Shaping up to be the most competitive season yet.

[NDman]

My top-3 prediction: The Volt brothers and Jennifer. Those 3 look very strong. Kevin certainly doesn't have the aura or swagger but he sure looks pretty strong too. I think he has a decent shot too.

Outside of those, I can't think of anyone who really stand out.

That said though, they may have great skills and qualities in the kitchen, I am missing the Fabios, Stefans, Carlas and Jamies this season

[bembol]

My top-3 prediction: The Volt brothers and Jennifer. Those 3 look very strong. Kevin certainly doesn't have the aura or swagger but he sure looks pretty strong too. I think he has a decent shot too.

Outside of those, I can't think of anyone who really stand out.

That said though, they may have great skills and qualities in the kitchen, I am missing the Fabios, Stefans, Carlas and Jamies this season

+1

Fabio in the Bachelorette party. :twisted:

[thelefteyeguy]

top chef on break last week?

[bembol]

No, why?

I can't believe Hector went home last week. I can't remember the judges really focused how terrible it was sliced/servered while Mattin tried using Bacon to save the dish.


Not surprised that my Top 3 (the Volt Brothers & Kevin) continues to dominate.

As for tonight's episode. I keep wondering if these people watch the show/previous seasons because when you are in the bottom for elimination...

SHUT THE **** UP, DON'T BE COCKY and/or ADMIT YOU MADE MISTAKES.

Then again, I think Marteen got lucky last week...

[somemale]

Out of the strongest four: 2 bros, Kevin and Jennifer, I'm guessing at least one of them will NOT make it to the finals. The EC from the losing team of restaurant wars always goes home. No way they will all be on one team, and I'm sure they would not shy away from being EC.

Already can't wait for the episode!

[tyrrell]

My top-3 prediction: The Volt brothers and Jennifer. Those 3 look very strong. Kevin certainly doesn't have the aura or swagger but he sure looks pretty strong too. I think he has a decent shot too.

Outside of those, I can't think of anyone who really stand out.

That said though, they may have great skills and qualities in the kitchen, I am missing the Fabios, Stefans, Carlas and Jamies this season

Yeah they are the most talented crew. But not the most interesting group to watch. No real interesting personalities.

[Migger]

My wife and I just stumbled upon this show recently and we love it. I agree with most people's comments about the brothers and Jennifer... which one is Kevin? Is he the guy with the dark, faux-hawkish hair?

[smokieboy]

I hate that lady host they have. She is terrible and has no personality. It pains me to watch this show because she is soooooooooo bad.
I usually have to watch the shows online and skip through her parts.
I think one of the brothers should get it.

[BD006]

I hate that lady host they have. She is terrible and has no personality. It pains me to watch this show because she is soooooooooo bad.
I usually have to watch the shows online and skip through her parts.
I think one of the brothers should get it.

Padma? Are you kidding me? :eek:

I take it you never watched the first season with Katie Lee Joel, now there was someone who brought no personality to the show.

My picks from the first couple weeks were also the Voltaggio bros, Jen and Kevin. Michael V gave everyone a pretty big scare last week, I thought he was a goner for sure.

I still think the judging should be based on their entire tenure on the show, and not week by week, though I think they do sometimes look the other way a bit when they know one of the stronger competitors is on the hot seat. The one I'll never forget was when they actually sent Trey home in season 3 Miami, I had him the final four for sure.

[smokieboy]

Padma? Are you kidding me? :eek:

I take it you never watched the first season with Katie Lee Joel, now there was someone who brought no personality to the show.

My picks from the first couple weeks were also the Voltaggio bros, Jen and Kevin. Michael V gave everyone a pretty big scare last week, I thought he was a goner for sure.

I still think the judging should be based on their entire tenure on the show, and not week by week, though I think they do sometimes look the other way a bit when they know one of the stronger competitors is on the hot seat. The one I'll never forget was when they actually sent Trey home in season 3 Miami, I had him the final four for sure.

Yeah Padma that's it.
She sucks big time. No personality at all. Even when she's pissed she shows nothing. It's like the attack of the pod people all over again.
I don't know who Katie Lee Joel so I guess I'll take your word on her.
No I didn't see that season. It seems the idiots that run the show still haven't learned how to pick a good host yet.

[slowtyper]

I like Padma. She doesn't show much personality but I DO NOT WANT HER TO! The first years host sucked. Did anyone watch Top Chef Masters with some asian chick as the host? You'll think Padma is awesome after watching those.

The host should not be showing too much emotion. Let the real chef judges handle that. Some of her comments during judging and tasting can be pretty painful however besides that, she isn't involved much except for introducing guests and explaining challenges. You don't really see her all that much.

[smokieboy]

I like Padma. She doesn't show much personality but I DO NOT WANT HER TO! The first years host sucked. Did anyone watch Top Chef Masters with some asian chick as the host? You'll think Padma is awesome after watching those.

The host should not be showing too much emotion. Let the real chef judges handle that. Some of her comments during judging and tasting can be pretty painful however besides that, she isn't involved much except for introducing guests and explaining challenges. You don't really see her all that much.

Gee what a surprise that I disagree with you.........again.:lol:
The host should show emotion because it's the host you see most of the time introducing everyone and everything. There's no excitement,thrill, passion from her which drags the show down. Doesn't matter how rude the judges are you still don't get excited about stuff before the end when the judges give everyone s@@@.

It is really creepy to see a smiling judge standing next to Padma who is so emotionless. She's like a robot. Then you have the grinning idiot judge standing next to her.........yukes!

[slowtyper]

I guess you are right that a differnet host may appeal to some viewers but I can honestly say that I don't give a crap what the host has to say. I'm watching the show because I enjoy watching the chefs cook and explain what they come up with and how they do it. To a less extent, I enjoy hearing what the judges have to say. I don't give a crap what Padma has to say but she is nice to look briefly.

I'd recommend you try to watch an episode of the first season and of the recent Top Chef Masters and see your reaction to the hostings there.

Next episode I'll time how long Padma is actually talking during the episode. I'm guessing its about 1.5 minutes total.

[bembol]

Compared to the first Season's host Katie Lee Joel, Padma is an Emmy winner! LOL

She's just a host aka to attract viewers, which IMO she did. Honestly, who pays attention to her criticism/reviews. :twisted:


Anyways, last night Quick Fire challenge was a JOKE!!! Michelle Bernstein, who I love and strong judging in Top Chef gave Robin a sympathy vote. I called her out from the beginning and I think she doesn't belong here.

[smokieboy]

I guess you are right that a differnet host may appeal to some viewers but I can honestly say that I don't give a crap what the host has to say. I'm watching the show because I enjoy watching the chefs cook and explain what they come up with and how they do it. To a less extent, I enjoy hearing what the judges have to say. I don't give a crap what Padma has to say but she is nice to look briefly.

I'd recommend you try to watch an episode of the first season and of the recent Top Chef Masters and see your reaction to the hostings there.

Next episode I'll time how long Padma is actually talking during the episode. I'm guessing its about 1.5 minutes total.

What channel are they on?
I honestly don't have much time to watch tv during the spring/summer/fall months due to my work. Even when I am on here, which isn't much, I am usually double tasking like working on the forklift, cleaning out the coolers or fixing something.

From what I saw I don't find that many of the chefs know what the hell they are doing. So I really don't care what they have to say. It's always some excuse on why they screwed up or blaming someone else for their mistakes.

As for the judges I don't think they really care that the person knows how to cook only if they are great onscreen. I remember watching bits and pieces of one chef ending show where some lady who was a terrible cook won over a guy who had great dishes all along, mainly because of her onscreen presence.

Even the recipe she cooked was fake as it was taken from another site from years back yet she claims she had it all along or so the story in many forums goes. You'll probably know what series it was if you watch thses programs.

The winner was an older blond woman who complained alot and the guy was tall, lanky and had curly type hair, kramer like.

[slowtyper]

From what I saw I don't find that many of the chefs know what the hell they are doing. So I really don't care what they have to say. It's always some excuse on why they screwed up or blaming someone else for their mistakes.


Some of the chefs are very talented and I enjoy watching those and rooting for the crappy ones to go home.



As for the judges I don't think they really care that the person knows how to cook only if they are great onscreen. I remember watching bits and pieces of one chef ending show where some lady who was a terrible cook won over a guy who had great dishes all along, mainly because of her onscreen presence.

Even the recipe she cooked was fake as it was taken from another site from years back yet she claims she had it all along or so the story in many forums goes. You'll probably know what series it was if you watch thses programs.

The winner was an older blond woman who complained alot and the guy was tall, lanky and had curly type hair, kramer like.

I don't know which episode you are referring to but I can assure you that no final elimination has obviously been due to onscreen presence. I don't think it was a season winner because there was only one female top chef final winner and she had performed well and was talented though the runner up was also very good and in my opinion (based on the season) the better chef.

The thing is that each episode (and even the final) is supposed to be based on that performance alone. You can be the best chef every episode and if you mess up on the final someone else can luckbox into the winning seat. This has been what the judges have said many times however I don't believe it 100%. I do not believe that a bad cook would have been chosen due to onscreen presence at all. I think if you read some of the head chef judge Tom Collichio (sp?)'s blogs, this is fairly evident. This guy isn't making a ton of money from being a chef judge on a tv show, he is a restauranter first and foremost. The guest judges like Jacque Pepin and Eric Ripert certainly don't give a crap about onscreen presence.

As for "stolen recipies" I think it happens all of the time. This season one of the contestants is the Chef de Cuisine for Eric Ripert. Is it any surprise she kicks out a kick ass fish dish that is probably served at that restaurant? I know there was one winner of the show that also made great dishes but it turned out those were all dishes served at a restaurant he worked at. Not his recipies but there is no rule on the show that you can't do it. Viewers feel ripped off though when that comes to light. You can even make the same dish multiple times during the season for different challenges.

[thelefteyeguy]

this is the best season by far in regards to talent...chemistry wise...not sure until i see the reunion...last years reunion was awesome :cheesygri



btw...i think there was a week off...

Sept 24 Episode 6
Oct 8 Episode 7
Oct 15 Episode 8

Was the Sept30/Oct1 week a recap?

[warlandsboy]

this is the best season by far in regards to talent...

+1 I totally agree on this!

Does anyone else here think Tom Colicchio's facial expressions are hilarious?!?

[bembol]

^ I have to agree because of The Volt Brothers, Kevin and Jennifer!

Not surprised they were the top players tonight and pretty much the past episodes. I would be shock if they do not make the finale.


Any RFD hate Robyn? I can't stand her and playing the Cancer card a few episodes ago made me even hate her more. Tonight, the other Chef's finally let her know how they really feel. One of the worst (Top) Chef's ever picked/casted.



EDIT: I just the preview for next week. Restaurant Wars!

*sigh* That woman is with The Volt Brothers... :( I won't say anymore becaue I already got a warning about my language. LOL

[carmaster]

I hate that lady host they have. She is terrible and has no personality. It pains me to watch this show because she is soooooooooo bad.
I usually have to watch the shows online and skip through her parts.
I think one of the brothers should get it.

+1

She is the worst tv host I have seen and adds no value to the show. She has no skills both on the hosting side and tasting side. I like the show otherwise.

[Fear]

+1

She is the worst tv host I have seen and adds no value to the show. She has no skills both on the hosting side and tasting side. I like the show otherwise.

who cares

she's beautiful

[MaximDude]

Can someone tell me where Eve and I think Jesse is? Everytime I see a Top Chef commercial on the Food Channel you see Eve yelling at the camera, yet I don't think I've ever seen her on the show. Did she and Jesse get knocked off early or something?

Also, I really hope Jennifer and Kevin make it to the finals. My favorites of the season so far. :) Those two and one of the brothers would make a damn good finals.

And also I really dislike Mike. Too cocky and I really don't like that he shows so much contempt and disrespect to Robin. He's more talented than her sure, but do you have to literally tell it to her face that you don't like her and don't think she's talented enough? Robin is like Tiffani from season 1 where some if not all people dislike her now.

[sannin]

No clear front runner for this season compared to the rest.

Talent-wise, this season just blows the previous ones out of the water.

Final Four should be: Voltaggio bros, Jen and Kevin.

Winner would be between the 2 V bros.

[Brandon]

I don't know which episode you are referring to but I can assure you that no final elimination has obviously been due to onscreen presence. I don't think it was a season winner because there was only one female top chef final winner and she had performed well and was talented though the runner up was also very good and in my opinion (based on the season) the better chef.


I think he's referring to another show, The Next Food Network Star (something like that).

But that show was different, they're specifically looking for someone who has good presentation talent (because the winner will get to host their own show). The people competing in that show were mostly just regular people who like to cook (at home cooks). I don't think any of the participants in that show had any long term formal training.

[doubloonie]

Can someone tell me where Eve and I think Jesse is? Everytime I see a Top Chef commercial on the Food Channel you see Eve yelling at the camera, yet I don't think I've ever seen her on the show. Did she and Jesse get knocked off early or something?

Also, I really hope Jennifer and Kevin make it to the finals. My favorites of the season so far. :) Those two and one of the brothers would make a damn good finals.

And also I really dislike Mike. Too cocky and I really don't like that he shows so much contempt and disrespect to Robin. He's more talented than her sure, but do you have to literally tell it to her face that you don't like her and don't think she's talented enough? Robin is like Tiffani from season 1 where some if not all people dislike her now.

Eve and Jesse were voted off quite early - Eve in Episode 2 for cooking bad shrimp dishes 2 weeks in a row and Jesse in Episode 4 for cooking a terrible snail dish and not being able to redeem herself with her amuse bouche.

I don't know why Robin is still around, she's useless in the kitchen. Even though nobody liked Tiffini in Season 1, at least she had actual talent.

I agree with most people here wrt to the final 4: Kevin, Jen and the 2 Volts.

The last episode was amazing with the relay cooking quickfire. I don't think any of the past season's contestants could have carried off what this season is doing.

[ArcLyte]

ahh Mikey and his arrogance finally caught up with him. Add insult to injury he gets the boot before Robin does! Looks like Jennifer is having a breakdown... I wonder if she'll lose it and get booted next episode or return to form.

[Brandon]

The last episode was amazing with the relay cooking quickfire. I don't think any of the past season's contestants could have carried off what this season is doing.

I think this season has a better top end (other seasons usually had 2 really good chefs), with 3-4 really good chefs, but the rest seem to be on par with other seasons.

For example, if we swap Jenner with Hung from a previous season, the top 4 would be Hung, 2x Volts and Kevin. That'd be a cool end of season (I think Kevin would win).

[99SiR]

Padma HAS a lot of personality :confused: , and she's hot....I've seen no one mention any of her old material, she had a traveling cooking show exploring different ethnic cuisine some of it was really informative and interesting, she has a respectful way about her and is pretty innocent as her words keep getting twisted sexually on the show at her expense. She does have some rough comments at times and she definitely has a good palette and can cook, thats why she's a judge too.....oh shes got a hair commercial too....oh did i mention she's hot?

It's gonna be one of the brothers and the big boy at the end for sure.....

[bembol]

This season's RESTAURANT WARS wasn't even close.

I was surprised because it was pretty much between Jennifer & Kevin vs The Volt Brothers.

Jennifer's team "Mission," failed at pretty much everything and even backed down from doing a Dessert. Laurine handling the Front of the House, was so wrong since she has No Personality!

I wasn't surprised that Jennifer didn't go home, even though her dishes was disappointing.

I really that my sister, after reading the credits back in Season Three said that Producers have a saying who gets voted off. :evil:

Of course, this brings up Robyn who once again got LUCKY and survives another week! :evil:

[BD006]

ahh Mikey and his arrogance finally caught up with him. Add insult to injury he gets the boot before Robin does! Looks like Jennifer is having a breakdown... I wonder if she'll lose it and get booted next episode or return to form.

Can't believe Robin is still around.

And I hope Jen is able to pull it together. She's had two abysmal weeks in a row, but from what we've seen, she has the talent and deserves to be in the final 4.

[99SiR]

Lets be real a lot of the chefs at the beginning do their restaurants dishes in the early rounds, that is why Jen was so good. Put her into a situation where she has to innovate and be under some pressure, she cracks. No doubt she can cook but does she have the full package. Even one of the brothers used another chef's dish he worked with, the bananna polenta and got rave reviews.....This competition begs for originality and creativity......and that's who will win.

[slowtyper]

I really that my sister, after reading the credits back in Season Three said that Producers have a saying who gets voted off. :evil:


Tom Collichio made a blog post about this a few times adamantly denying that the producers have any influence during regular judging. The post was quite long and very believable. It is there in case of extreme cases where the producers may have to step in. If you watched the season with that wolverine guy's hair (his name started with an M...), Tom wanted to kick off a bunch of contestants for bad behavior but he said the producers stepped in and would not allow it.

[slowtyper]

This competition begs for originality and creativity......and that's who will win.

Tell that to richard from the last season

[shannn]

Tell that to richard from the last season

Touche

And look at what happened last season.

Having no desert won.

---

So I finally caught up on all the episodes.

Talent pool is great this year.

I must say, Robin has gotten lucky a lot this season. Winning immunity a couple times, then just getting by because another chef melted down each time.

By the way, this last vegetarian episode, I can't believe they were talking about fellatio for 1 or 2 minutes :lol:

---

I think in the finals, we will see Kevin (he looks like Alan from the hangover), the V brothers (one of whom looks like Tony Hawk), and Jennifer

---

I'm really enjoying this season. It is running with season 3 as one of my favorites

But I reallllly hope they go back to having the finals as 1 vs. 1 with the 2 sous being the 2 runners up

[bembol]

Natalie Portman looks amazing, I wasn't surprised when Tom said she's Vegeterian, I knew there was a twist.

It's pure BS that Robin is still here, not that I like Mike either. He has a cocky/poor attitude, it's what sent him home.

What do you think of Michael getting upset that they picked Kevin's dish? I thought it was a slap in the face.

[carmaster]

Great episode yesterday. Clearly Kevin and the brothers are the front runners. Jennifer was strong in the beginning, but is really cracking under pressure. She will be gone next week with Robin.

[shannn]

What do you think of Michael getting upset that they picked Kevin's dish? I thought it was a slap in the face.

Tony Hawk was pissed.
I think he may have forgotten one important rule: Simplicity is sometimes best.

I think Kevin takes the competition because he is so versatile. Like when he cooked an asian dish without experience in asian cuisine.

I'm surprised that no previous top chef winners have been guest judges so far.

[MaximDude]

What happened to Jennifer?? :( She was so awesome in the beginning, winning challenges and finishing at the top of the group almost everytime. And now the last couple of weeks she's going down in flames. :|

I hope Jen can get it together because I really want to see what kind of menu she would come up with in the finals.

Also I'm not a fan of Robyn, but I'm glad she outlasted that cocky bastard Michael though. He's a good chef, but I think the Volts, Kevin and Jen are all better than him, yet he thinks of himself as a frontrunner and always talks like he's the sh$t. Good to see his cocky, desrespectful ass OUT!

[shannn]

So...Robyn is FINALLY gone. Her being left in the final 6 was worse than Leah from last season. I mean, at least Leah could cook, Robyn was wayyyy out of her league

And oh man, Jenn is really burning out. She has to come back strong, or she's done.

I still think it will be Tony Hawk, Bryan, Kevin and Jennifer in the end, with Kevin taking it all

[slowtyper]

I know the chefs always say you are judged on this one performance ONLY but I don't really believe that. It doesn't seem like Robyn screwed up that much. I think Jen or Eli should technically have gone home but they spared them because they had performed better in the past. Even at the judges Tom Collichio seemed to be "coaching" Robyn to say how she was trying to reach too far and then used that as the reason for sending her home.

[shannn]

I know the chefs always say you are judged on this one performance ONLY but I don't really believe that. It doesn't seem like Robyn screwed up that much. I think Jen or Eli should technically have gone home but they spared them because they had performed better in the past. Even at the judges Tom Collichio seemed to be "coaching" Robyn to say how she was trying to reach too far and then used that as the reason for sending her home.

But they also criticized her lack of ability/skill, saying that her dish should have been easy to make, but didn't turn out well.

Whereas Jenn's dish was weak, but the level of difficulty was there in hers. Eli's dish was too complex and needed more thought/execution.

In that respect, I believe Robyn was correctly sent home. This is of course all IMO

---

But I do agree that chefs are judged on their performance that day and of previous days. I think Stefan last season was saved because of that (and several other chefs from previous seasons)

[bembol]

Finally!!!!! Robin is gone.


I think Michael will be the Top Chef this season. He continues to put out some Very Creative and Strong dishes.

[shannn]

Just like I predicted in the finals.

Kevin is going to win it all. Simplicity is always best :D

I wonder who the sous chefs this season will be in the finals