NW-S205F Vs. NW-E505 which is better?

[Aznkid2000]

I was wondering which mp3 player is better.

NW-S205F (http://img5.pcpop.com/ProductImages/500x375/0/230/000230970.jpg) Vs. NW-E505 (http://techdigestuk.typepad.com/tech_digest/images/wimge500.jpg)

The NW-E505 is 40$ while the NW-S205F is 50$

They are both the 1Gb model.

I like both of there design and how its small and portable

If there are other mp3 player that you guys recommand please tell me.

Please help me pick one.

Thanks

[Aznkid2000]

anyone?

[Zerius]

E505, it has a better feel to it. The mp3 battery is better the screen is better and its less ugly and bulky

[ES_Revenge]

I think it's mainly preference. Personally I like the S205F better but that's just me.

It's probably better for you to ask this question here (http://www.minidisct.com/forum) or here (http://www.atraclife.com/forums/) as you will get more insight and a better reply as many people on these forums are familiar with these devices ;)

[Aznkid2000]

anyone more help please..

[SuPaFleXx]

definitely the E505. but if u excessively drop either player, the mechanism that changes the track will break, and it is quite easy to break.

[Aznkid2000]

alright thanks guys

I'll just wait few more days to see anymore comments