Why is Costco so expensive?

[gamer4Life]

I did a price check on various items found around Costco vs items found at RCSS and Save On Foods -- I found most things at Costco are more expensive or roughly the same per unit price.

I've always figured that they were cheaper because you buy in bulk and because you pay for "membership", as well as having a very warehouse type feel to their stores. They must make a killing on overcharging people for their foods.

I compared all sorts of meat with Save-on, and Save-on came out cheaper all the time. The only thing cheaper at Costco was the HP steak sauce. I'm sure there are other items that Costco is cheaper at, but if my sample is accurate, then it's not really worth going to shop at Costco for food, let alone paying a membership fee.

Does anybody know the meats they sell at Save-on? I assume they're AAA, not that I know what the difference is.

[CSK'sMom]

Check the labels on the meat at grocery stores. You will rarely find AAA beef. Usually it says A-AA. When it has the A-AA range on the packaging chances are that it's only A grade and a very small percentage of the run would be AA. A is the lowest grading and AAA is the highest. Costco's beef is always AAA and most of it is also prime grade as well which means it's the grade of meat that one would usually find at a high end butcher of a really good restaurant...

[3weddings]

Check the labels on the meat at grocery stores. You will rarely find AAA beef. Usually it says A-AA. When it has the A-AA range on the packaging chances are that it's only A grade and a very small percentage of the run would be AA. A is the lowest grading and AAA is the highest. Costco's beef is always AAA and most of it is also prime grade as well which means it's the grade of meat that one would usually find at a high end butcher of a really good restaurant...

You took the words right out of my mouth!! We never buy grocery store meat, we buy organic in St Jacobs, but I will from Costco.

Also, compare Orange Juice and bread. You will find a massive saving.

[CSK'sMom]

And milk! When we run out and can't make it across the border we buy milk only at Costco. It's always cheaper than grocery or corner stores. :)

[3weddings]

And milk! When we run out and can't make it across the border we buy milk only at Costco. It's always cheaper than grocery or corner stores. :)

Absolutely...it was when the kids were on Homo that my Costco addiction started! ;)

Can't forget about the clothing area either! I buy sweat socks and a pack of JoeBoxers for dh every time I am in! Where else can you find $30 Dockers and Jeans under $12 for the kids?

[Phr3sh]

Hrmmm....ive never tried the meat there....sounds really good though

[cloneman]

Costco used to be great years ago, when there was very little competition in general.
There was simply no better place to buy appliances/televisions/mattresses even computers. Nearly everything was cheaper.

Most food is still a little cheaper as far as I know...

Now their prices are just "reasonable/warm".

Anyone else still call it Club Price? :D

[NiftyScent]

Costco used to be great years ago, when there was very little competition in general.
There was simply no better place to buy appliances/televisions/mattresses even computers. Nearly everything was cheaper.

Most food is still a little cheaper as far as I know...

Now their prices are just "reasonable/warm".

Anyone else still call it Club Price? :D
Nope, Price Club!

[Anessa]

Yeah it's true that No Frills and RCSS can match them for prices. I think most people just shop their to a) get their cash rebate on the black card b) cash rebate on both black and platinum cards c) they just like the selection or d) it's just more convenient. I know there's a Costco closer to me than RCSS or Walmart superstore.

Oh, and the return policy ;)

[onehaehyuk]

Yeah, my family's always been big on the meat at Costco. Their meat is top notch and the price is pretty good too considering the quality.

I was wondering, me and my fam always go to Costco to do "wholesale" shopping but I've never been to the other large wholesale company, Sam's Club. Anyone know if Sam's Club is comparable in terms of prices, products etc.? I've always been curious because i never hear ppl. talk about Sam's Club, most ppl. i know all go to Costco still.

[Impossibles]

And it's not that Costco is expensive, its that other stores are following the same model of large quantities at very low margins.

We go there once a month, what I find are good prices are: over the counter medications, sauces, canned veggies (tomatoes), meats, books, zip loc bags, breads, and frozen foods.

[Steeve Urkel]

I find Costco is ok, they have a good selection of gifts.

But for regular food, esp frozen items they are not cheaper.
Food basics just had a sale on frozen Stoufers skillets and I paid $1 a package, Costco would probably be $5.

Costco does have cheap Starbucks coffee, but not sure how "real" it is, as they only have one kind.

I don't live near Costco anymore so don't shop there.
But I do miss the fast food section where they had the giant ice cream cones and fries

[3weddings]

I was wondering, me and my fam always go to Costco to do "wholesale" shopping but I've never been to the other large wholesale company, Sam's Club. Anyone know if Sam's Club is comparable in terms of prices, products etc.? I've always been curious because i never hear ppl. talk about Sam's Club, most ppl. i know all go to Costco still.

We used Sam's for a year, but because it was not convenient location wise, went back to Costco. Pricing is about $0.01 different either way, and the selection is very similar. The one thing I do miss is WonderBread and the mini croissants (Costco doesn't offer either). They also seemed to have a great selection of clothes and seasonal items. I have to admit I enjoyed Sam's, and if they were closer, I probably would have both memberships. ;)

[chadw01]

And milk! When we run out and can't make it across the border we buy milk only at Costco. It's always cheaper than grocery or corner stores. :)

You have to wait in those huge lineups just for one item? There's always one person who always looks funny carrying one item in hand while waiting at the cash lineup. :)

Why doesn't Costco have express lines for people with very little items???

[sergiepopov]

I have both costco and sam's, and I find that the groceries and meat I buy at costco are always better quality than sam's. Manufactured goods are almost the same, except for in house brand, where costco is the winner again.

[3weddings]

You have to wait in those huge lineups just for one item? There's always one person who always looks funny carrying one item in hand while waiting at the cash lineup. :)

Why doesn't Costco have express lines for people with very little items???

LOL...because they don't want us buying just one item!! lol

If you go early or at about 2pm it's pretty dead in both stores! ;)

[BD006]

Me and my parents also feel Costco and Sam's are hit-and-miss in terms of prices. There are only select items that we buy from either, as my parents are huge on price comparing.

[CSK'sMom]

You have to wait in those huge lineups just for one item? There's always one person who always looks funny carrying one item in hand while waiting at the cash lineup. :)

Why doesn't Costco have express lines for people with very little items???

Uhmmm... we go through a minimum of a 4 litre bag of milk a day in this house, more often than not, 2 bags. When we run in for milk only, we buy 5-10 bags depending on when we are planning to cross the border again to buy 10 or 15 gallons of milk. ;)

[gamer4Life]

Check the labels on the meat at grocery stores. You will rarely find AAA beef. Usually it says A-AA. When it has the A-AA range on the packaging chances are that it's only A grade and a very small percentage of the run would be AA. A is the lowest grading and AAA is the highest. Costco's beef is always AAA and most of it is also prime grade as well which means it's the grade of meat that one would usually find at a high end butcher of a really good restaurant...

Only RCSS has labels on their meats and it says AA or higher. I can't find any labels on Costco meats or Save-on meats.

Just wondering, where did you get the information that Costco meats are AAA? Also, is there a grading system for chicken as well? Because Save-on and RCSS are both cheaper.

As for other things, like canned fish, 1 L juice, cereal, it's actually more expensive, and you get the inconvenience of buying so many at a time. With other stores you can just buy as many as you need.

[CSK'sMom]

Carefully read the labels both on the meat itself and at the meat counter. All the information is there, it has to be by law. ;) Canned fish (tuna in particular) is much cheaper at Costco when buying the institutional size. Cereal is cheaper as well, for instance the large box of Shreddies is $7.99 at Zehrs and it's usually $5.99 at Costco. We only buy "healthy" creals, no sugary junk. Costco is not for everyone, especially singles who don't like to shop in bulk. For those of us with families who only shop in bulk we come out way ahead.

[SCRawl]

Uhmmm... we go through a minimum of a 4 litre bag of milk a day in this house, more often than not, 2 bags. When we run in for milk only, we buy 5-10 bags depending on when we are planning to cross the border again to buy 10 or 15 gallons of milk. ;)

I was always wondering about that. When I go to Costco,there's almost always one or two people with either a cart or a flatbed absolutely full of milk. I figured that they were convenience store operators, but now I know, they just like milk! :razz:

Seriously, I go there two or three times per week, for (at least) the milk: we have one- and three-year-old girls, so milk is definitely a staple product here. Bread, meat, yogurt, and lots of other products are similarly well priced, and their weekly coupons & sales help. It's true, for many products you can do better elsewhere, but ask yourself this: have you ever purchased crap from Costco? I don't think I ever have -- it's always superior quality stuff.

[shari2002]

so how much is the milk there?

I was always wondering about that. When I go to Costco,there's almost always one or two people with either a cart or a flatbed absolutely full of milk. I figured that they were convenience store operators, but now I know, they just like milk! :razz:

Seriously, I go there two or three times per week, for (at least) the milk: we have one- and three-year-old girls, so milk is definitely a staple product here. Bread, meat, yogurt, and lots of other products are similarly well priced, and their weekly coupons & sales help. It's true, for many products you can do better elsewhere, but ask yourself this: have you ever purchased crap from Costco? I don't think I ever have -- it's always superior quality stuff.

[tkyoshi]

so how much is the milk there?

Here in GVA it's around $3.50 for 4L 2%, same as Safeway.

[HighFlyer]

so how much is the milk there?

$3.95 in GTA

[djjosee]

You have to wait in those huge lineups just for one item? There's always one person who always looks funny carrying one item in hand while waiting at the cash lineup. :)

Why doesn't Costco have express lines for people with very little items???

Cause they want you to buy more!

Costco is the closest store to me ... I can actulaly walk there, where I would have to drive to any other grocery/convenient store. So, I've done the one item purchase several times ... you just have to know when to go.

[The_Madz]

bah costco isn't really that cheap with milk even

I prefer buying at places like Reids dairy.. it's cheap and good and for me tastes better.. plus as a bonus they have $0.99 1L chocolate milk as regular price and also $1 milk shakes! :)


sure it's an extra stop but hey it's closer than a costco for me

[CatDog]

have you ever purchased crap from Costco? I don't think I ever have -- it's always superior quality stuff.


in mississauga there entire baking section sucks, their bread, cookies and muffins.. yuck.

Meats are good, and I got a 42" Samsung DLP with stand for $1k

[Slapshot747]

You have to wait in those huge lineups just for one item? There's always one person who always looks funny carrying one item in hand while waiting at the cash lineup. :)

Why doesn't Costco have express lines for people with very little items???

I agree totally they should have lines for people with less items..Some times i want to go in and get 1 sale item and get out and i see the long line and walk back out...But i guess costco dont care about that type of shopper ..:mad:

[wrigley]

Only RCSS has labels on their meats and it says AA or higher. I can't find any labels on Costco meats or Save-on meats.

Just wondering, where did you get the information that Costco meats are AAA? Also, is there a grading system for chicken as well? Because Save-on and RCSS are both cheaper.

As for other things, like canned fish, 1 L juice, cereal, it's actually more expensive, and you get the inconvenience of buying so many at a time. With other stores you can just buy as many as you need.

Costco usually has a sign telling their meat is AA or better.

Their pharmacy is much cheaper than a local SDM, dispensing fee is only $4.99

[GYR8]

Only RCSS has labels on their meats and it says AA or higher. I can't find any labels on Costco meats or Save-on meats.

Just wondering, where did you get the information that Costco meats are AAA? Also, is there a grading system for chicken as well? Because Save-on and RCSS are both cheaper.

As for other things, like canned fish, 1 L juice, cereal, it's actually more expensive, and you get the inconvenience of buying so many at a time. With other stores you can just buy as many as you need.

Each location should have something like this posted:
http://img264.imageshack.us/img264/8665/aaabeefwr6.th.jpg (http://img264.imageshack.us/my.php?image=aaabeefwr6.jpg)

GYR8

[Keelie]

i dont find costco to be all that expensive, sure there are some items that are comparable in price to other stores, but when an item goes on sale its really a good buy.

there are certain things i stock up on when they are on sale and then i dont need them again until they are on sale. you cant beat the sale price of ziplock bags!! and thats only one example of many.

like others have said, the meat is great. i buy whole pork loins, and i've not seen them in a regular store on sale for cheaper then regular price at costco.
the whole chickens, 3 to a bag, are a great price and huge in size. they work out to $6-7 each.
steaks i normally buy at the butcher because i prefer to buy fresh and dont need a big package, but costco is the only other place i would buy them.

not to mention clothes and housewares, not only great prices, but lots of things you wont see in other stores.

and dont get me started on the jewelery ;)

[LonesomeDove]

I suppose you can get things cheaper if you wait for sales and shop around but if time is important, why waste time runing around looking for bargains when everything at Costco is equivalent to sale prices elsewhere.

[GYR8]

and dont get me started on the jewelery ;)

What was that Keelie? You want to come to my location and purchase a Brietling? :lol:

GYR8

[djjosee]

Costco usually has a sign telling their meat is AA or better.

Their pharmacy is much cheaper than a local SDM, dispensing fee is only $4.99

Check the "Costco Facts" on the right hand side:

http://www.getmoreofwhatyoulove.ca/

[patrob]

$3.95 in GTA

We used to buy our milk always at Costco when it used to be around $3.60 or less...then we switched to SDM, since it's pretty much the same now...plus Costco is not around the corner either... Now whenever we go to Costco, we make it into a "trip" :D

I noticed that many everyday items can be found for the same price elsewhere...of course there are exceptions...but I was actually thinking of canceling our membership & would just share one with my mom :lol:

[TrevorK]

I did a price check on various items found around Costco vs items found at RCSS and Save On Foods -- I found most things at Costco are more expensive or roughly the same per unit price.

I've always figured that they were cheaper because you buy in bulk and because you pay for "membership", as well as having a very warehouse type feel to their stores. They must make a killing on overcharging people for their foods.

I compared all sorts of meat with Save-on, and Save-on came out cheaper all the time. The only thing cheaper at Costco was the HP steak sauce. I'm sure there are other items that Costco is cheaper at, but if my sample is accurate, then it's not really worth going to shop at Costco for food, let alone paying a membership fee.

Does anybody know the meats they sell at Save-on? I assume they're AAA, not that I know what the difference is.

I'd be curious to see the actual brands and prices you are comparing.

I've found that, for the most part, Costco is always equal to or lower than any other stores regular price. This makes it great for many of us that don't have time to shop 4 different stores for a sale price.

Sure the Kirkland brand can't compete with the No-Name brand, but it's not meant to because the quality is different.

[Jon Lai]

Does anybody know the meats they sell at Save-on? I assume they're AAA, not that I know what the difference is.

AAA is a much higher quality meat, highest rating in Canada in fact. You'll taste the difference when you put it in your mouth.

I doubt Save On Foods sell AAA meat - it's much more expensive. AFAIK, only Longos, Loblaws, Dominion, and Sobeys sells AAA meat apart from Costco. All the other cheaper places sell AA or lower.

[mlc2000]

We buy a whole Rib eye or a whole top sirloin, you can save about $4-6/kg if you cut and wrap it yourself. We have a vacuum sealer for this.

We've never had a bad steak in 5 yrs.

Also, the prices for books is very good. Always head to Costco before a vacation, to pick up a book.

The prices on clothes is pretty good. Tommy, CK and Dockers cotton pants are always about $20 less than everywhere else. Nike Coolmax shirts for under $20 is pretty decent.

Yes, some products are more expensive - I think u can get a case of pop cheaper elsewhere.

[Keelie]

yes, books.. forgot about those!

i get a regular magazine there every month. price is $3.50, costco price is $2.60. i have a paperback book right here, book price is $13.95, costco price is $7.59. you cant beat those prices.

and the cookbooks.. the prices are great. i have a few of one kind that are $19.99, and i got them at costco for $9.99 each.

[gojetsgo]

This is an interesting comparison:

http://www.debtfreegrad.com/new_mr/mr_current/mr_may_2002/FS_warehousechart_may02.htm

It's a few years old, but I bet it is still relevant. From the looks of it to me, Costco is cheaper with some items and more expensive with others. It seems to even out. Overall, it's probably not worth getting a membership.

Also, if you take into account that RCSS has supercheap generic items, then you come out way ahead there. I challenge anyone to tell the difference between PC cola and Coke. When it's on sale, you can get a 24 pack for $3.99.

[mart242]

We buy a whole Rib eye or a whole top sirloin, you can save about $4-6/kg if you cut and wrap it yourself. We have a vacuum sealer for this.


Do you pre-freeze it a bit before vacuuming? I had an issue last time that all the blood was sucked from the meat... I'll try pre-freezing next time.

[Bytown]

This is an interesting comparison:

http://www.debtfreegrad.com/new_mr/mr_current/mr_may_2002/FS_warehousechart_may02.htm

It's a few years old, but I bet it is still relevant. From the looks of it to me, Costco is cheaper with some items and more expensive with others. It seems to even out. Overall, it's probably not worth getting a membership.

Also, if you take into account that RCSS has supercheap generic items, then you come out way ahead there. I challenge anyone to tell the difference between PC cola and Coke. When it's on sale, you can get a 24 pack for $3.99.

There is a deffernce.

[weedb0y]

although PC is pretty good for a store brand as compared to No-Name and others.

[vistaway]

I was recently given a membership as a gift after staying away for a few years. I was pretty disappointed to see that at least half of what we would have bought was more expensive, or the same price, as our normal stores. Milk was the same as shoppers, produce was way overpriced, general grocery and frozen was the same or more (as in the case of yogurt, cereal, bread, buns, toothpaste etc.).

I agree on the meat - it's great quality. But that doesn't make the membership worth it. I hold on to my Sam's one for cross-border shopping, and Costco is certainly handy for buying cases of microbrew beer in the states, but I couldn't justify to myself renewing on my own dime.

I think a lot of people are in the mindset that Costco is cheaper on everything and don't bother to actually analyze prices like a true RFDer would (down to the price per ounce/pound/kg/diaper/wipe/tube/etc.)

[blizzah]

A lot of things are cheaper, like Pizza Pops, pogos, milk, cereal, dry goods, detergent, books, chocolate and on and on. I find their seasonal items to also be very good, like the Callaway golf gloves 3 for 20$ where elsewhere it would be ~15$ each and their Vitamins. Also, it is a good place to buy huge packs of socks and other clothing. It only works if you have a large family, at least 4-5, to take advantage of the frozen stuff and huge packages of everything.

I still don't understand why their Coca cola is so expensive though.

[ferkel]

Costco is a profit driven company, making record profits each quarter for their shareholders. I don't shop at Costco because its way overpriced, just like their stock.

[Jon Lai]

I was recently given a membership as a gift after staying away for a few years. I was pretty disappointed to see that at least half of what we would have bought was more expensive, or the same price, as our normal stores. Milk was the same as shoppers, produce was way overpriced, general grocery and frozen was the same or more (as in the case of yogurt, cereal, bread, buns, toothpaste etc.).

I agree on the meat - it's great quality. But that doesn't make the membership worth it. I hold on to my Sam's one for cross-border shopping, and Costco is certainly handy for buying cases of microbrew beer in the states, but I couldn't justify to myself renewing on my own dime.

I think a lot of people are in the mindset that Costco is cheaper on everything and don't bother to actually analyze prices like a true RFDer would (down to the price per ounce/pound/kg/diaper/wipe/tube/etc.)

That's because most Costco shoppers don't pay for the membership just for groceries - that's not the point. We use our membership for electronics, books, medicine/perscriptions, photo, and of course the free samples. The groceries is just a convenience spinoff.

[HighFlyer]

I still don't understand why their Coca cola is so expensive though.
It's probably priced where it should be. Other stores have chosen to discount the product as a loss leader.

[Cheap Cat]

Like anywhere else, you have to know your prices. There are some amazing deals at Costco and some not so good deals. I don't buy canned goods, toilet paper and such at Costco because you can generally find it on sale cheaper elsewhere and I stock up when on sale. You will get good everyday prices on these items but not great prices. There are great deals on clothes, electronics, books, car batteries, small appliances, vitamins, contact lenses and glasses and so much more. Costco is also a fun place to shop as you never know what you'll find.

[patrob]

I challenge anyone to tell the difference between PC cola and Coke. When it's on sale, you can get a 24 pack for $3.99.

I have a Coke everyday & I can tell the difference:twisted: ...I have tried the PC a few times at my in-law's house:cheesygri & found big difference in taste...like they say, "...Can't Beat The Real Thing" :cheesygri ;)

Plus I never pay more than $4.99 for 24 cans...No Frills, SDM & Price Chopper have them on sale quite often...Costco's price is like $7 ...just crazy!!!

[3weddings]

I finally found something more expensive at Costco than at RCSS
12 Croissants are $5.99 at Costco and only $3.99 at RCSS!!!!

[patrob]

I finally found something more expensive at Costco than at RCSS
12 Croissants are $5.99 at Costco and only $3.99 at RCSS!!!!

Interesting, but I have only shopped there maybe 3 times, since not really close.....but we are supposed to be getting a brand new RCSS at the corner of Airport & Bovaird :twisted: so I can't wait.... Do you know if they price match:lol: like Wal-Mart:confused:

[alysomji]

You pay more because you are guaranteed satisfaction, can return practically anything at practically anytime (which includes, implicitly, great price protection - in case a Costco item drops in price within say six months), and don't need to spend extra for extended warranties (generally - as most problems happen in the first year and you can usually get Costco to take care of that for you).

If you're going to compare Costco prices to places like Loblaws, etc and that's it for your comparison then you're barking up the wrong tree already.

Costco is especially great for electronics and computer shoppers

[van]

I don't think anyone has mensioned it, but their tire prices are pretty low and beat out most of the competition.

[shoppingmama]

Like anywhere else, you have to know your prices. There are some amazing deals at Costco and some not so good deals. I don't buy canned goods, toilet paper and such at Costco because you can generally find it on sale cheaper elsewhere and I stock up when on sale. You will get good everyday prices on these items but not great prices. There are great deals on clothes, electronics, books, car batteries, small appliances, vitamins, contact lenses and glasses and so much more. Costco is also a fun place to shop as you never know what you'll find.

Exactly! I still go to RCSS for many of my canned goods but you cannot beat Costco for meat, bread, & their fresh fruit and veggies. Also Costco has stuff you cannot find in other grocery stores and that is just a few of the reasons I shop weekly at Costco and get a $250 cheque at the end of the year for shopping there :D

[mart242]

I finally found something more expensive at Costco than at RCSS
12 Croissants are $5.99 at Costco and only $3.99 at RCSS!!!!

I think that the costco ones are real butter and the rcss ones use margarine or some other butter substitute.

[gman]

Costco is a profit driven company, making record profits each quarter for their shareholders. I don't shop at Costco because its way overpriced, just like their stock.

Please suggest a commercial store which is not a profit driven company.

[blizzah]

Costco is a profit driven company, making record profits each quarter for their shareholders. I don't shop at Costco because its way overpriced, just like their stock.

Whats their stock have to do with anything, Google's stock is high, will you boycott using their search engine?

[cloneman]

costco doesn't have a price policy. You could probably find almost everything in their store cheaper elsewhere, if you tried hard enough. But MOST of the prices will be lower than the majority of competitors, that's why people buy food there. Your not gonna drive to 12 different stores because they have a sale on different types of fruit.

It's not written anywhere that costco MUST be cheaper than all other stores on ALL times.

[Cas77]

Costco is a profit driven company, making record profits each quarter for their shareholders. I don't shop at Costco because its way overpriced, just like their stock.

You must be from the Soviet Union. Welcome to Canada, hope you enjoy it here!

[bobcat99]

You pay more because you are guaranteed satisfaction, can return practically anything at practically anytime (which includes, implicitly, great price protection - in case a Costco item drops in price within say six months), and don't need to spend extra for extended warranties (generally - as most problems happen in the first year and you can usually get Costco to take care of that for you).

If you're going to compare Costco prices to places like Loblaws, etc and that's it for your comparison then you're barking up the wrong tree already.

Costco is especially great for electronics and computer shoppers

Plus RCSS and Loblaws only have a 14 day return/exchange policy which is nothing compared to most of the big stores.

[ferkel]

You must be from the Soviet Union. Welcome to Canada, hope you enjoy it here!

Da.... USSR is da best

[brule]

I know my printer ink is cheaper at costco (66$) for a canon mp530. It's always been cheaper than staples. The pricing at staples is stupid though, since the 2 packs aren't even cheaper than buying 2 single packs.. Which to me makes no sense.. Discount in bulk anyone?

Anyhow, costco stocks colour packs (Canon CLI-8 Colour Ink Combo Pack) with a Canon Black Ink Cartridge (PGI-5BK). I remember that these cost 65$ plus 22$ (for the black cartridge) at other stores. So I'm saving around 21$ each purchase. I know i could be saving money refilling my cartridges or using knock offs, but I've had colour issues when I got mine refilled on my epson.

[dinesh_zee]

Go GT Go!

*Giant Tiger

[davesaudio]

Pretty funny reasons for dissing Costco-
considering they take heat in the industry for paying employees more than average and providing benefits,
-more reasons to shop there

[malbadon]

Where is this mystical stores that sells my 2kg box of granola for cheaper than Costco?
Or my 50pounds of kitty litter for less than $5.
Or my tortellini 3pack for less than 12 bucks?
My 2 1kg loaves of rye bread for 4 bucks.
My 64 granola bars for 12 bucks.

It doesn't exist. That doesn't mean you buy every single item in the store.

Hell, I make my costco membership on kitty litter alone every year! (damn cats...)

[AlexK]

Only place that is cheaper in canada is DOLLAR STORE. hahaha.

[maidennomore]

I find eating in the cafeteria alone well worth the membership price. At .79c per coke, I have stocked up on a majority of my ICOKE points there.

[alv077]

All about the electronics.

My iPod's HD died and they just toke it, grabbed a new box, and just gave me a new one.

Extended warranty is one of those things I can't bring myself to buy. At Costco, it is free.

[pipolchap]

have you ever purchased crap from Costco? I don't think I ever have -- it's always superior quality stuff.

Try the large jug of Palmolive dish soap. Their stuff is diluted vs the usual concentrated stuff at regular stores.

[ullyeus]

Costco is a profit driven company, making record profits each quarter for their shareholders. I don't shop at Costco because its way overpriced, just like their stock.

We should all only shop at companies that are not profitable and are on the verge of bankruptcy.

[feminazi]

Costco has a policy of low margin profits, which in the U.S. I believe is somewhere around 6%, which is absurdly low in my opinion.

I assume Costco Canada is somewhat similar, but our dollar is probably helping their margins quite a bit. I wonder, if it stays up, will local Costco prices drop?

P.S. I forgot to mention their optical pricing, it is very sharp compared to an optometrist!!

Also, does the tire centre do wheel alignment? I hope so, since Crappy Tire charges 83 bucks for two-wheel alignment!

[kmltick]

I haven't come across a Costco that does 2 wheel alignments, it's pretty much tires. Not all Costco's do oil changes either.

[patriot]

Try the large jug of Palmolive dish soap. Their stuff is diluted vs the usual concentrated stuff at regular stores.

Were you able to determine that with your chemistry set ?

[patriot]

Also, does the tire centre do wheel alignment? I hope so, since Crappy Tire charges 83 bucks for two-wheel alignment!

They don't do alignment, but they do balance the tires.

[tienm23]

I guess it's not a question of is Costco expensive but rather, does it offer good value? The Dollar store is cheaper than Costco and RCSS but do you really want inferior quality meat or toothpaste?

For the $4.58 a month that membership costs, I feel I get this back many times over. The many benefits of being a member are definitely worth it for me.
i.e. $9.99 propane refill, high quality photofinishing (with $1.99 8x10), $27.00 oil changes, $1.99 hotdog and pop, free samples, low drug dispensing fee, AAA meats, cheap bestseller books, and the occasional hot deal ($29.97 rollerblades)

All of that, plus the best return policy in the business.

Although, Costco may not be the cheapest, it does offer great value.

[pipolchap]

Were you able to determine that with your chemistry set ?

Yes, and also through experience, genius...

[patriot]

Yes, and also through experience, genius...

Is the viscosity different ? Or does it just make less bubbles.

[gman]

Try the large jug of Palmolive dish soap. Their stuff is diluted vs the usual concentrated stuff at regular stores.

Did you try to shake the big jug? Big jug means the good stuff go to the bottom easier and the top portion to be diluted, just like any big jug of almost anything which is liquid from any store.

[tienm23]

Try the large jug of Palmolive dish soap. Their stuff is diluted vs the usual concentrated stuff at regular stores.

I doubt this would happen. A very small percentage of the cost of product is the actual soap, so there would be little incentive to dilute the product and reduce its effectiveness and potentially lose customers. Most of the cost of the product is shipping, packaging, marketing..etc.

[patriot]

I doubt this would happen. A very small percentage of the cost of product is the actual soap, so there would be little incentive to dilute the product and reduce its effectiveness and potentially lose customers. Most of the cost of the product is shipping, packaging, marketing..etc.

+1

[Impossibles]

Try the large jug of Palmolive dish soap. Their stuff is diluted vs the usual concentrated stuff at regular stores.

Sure you're not just buying regular vs 'ultra'?

[pipolchap]

Is the viscosity different ? Or does it just make less bubbles.

both

Sure you're not just buying regular vs 'ultra'?

that might be it... I'll never know cause I threw out the jug.

before i used the costco jug, a few drops usually did a bunch of dishes. the costco stuff took alot more.

Aside: whats the point of regular when they have the space-age technical ability to make a highly concentrated liquid? I think having a smaller bottle that does the same job as a jug is better value, and less weight.

[Cas77]

that might be it... I'll never know cause I threw out the jug.


That's the beauty of Costco...should've brought it back for a 100% refund.

[gman]

Aside: whats the point of regular when they have the space-age technical ability to make a highly concentrated liquid? I think having a smaller bottle that does the same job as a jug is better value, and less weight.

Just like everything else, regular is cheaper for the same volume. Consumer feels it is a better deal.

e.g. you have a concentrated version for $3. Your competitor has a regular version for $.99. Consumer will probably notice the $2 difference and buy your competitor's. If you also have a regular version, you cover that segment of customer.

Also, it depends on how many disc you wash too. For 1 dish, a drop of concentrated may be too much. A drop of regular may be perfect.

[Impossibles]

both



that might be it... I'll never know cause I threw out the jug.

before i used the costco jug, a few drops usually did a bunch of dishes. the costco stuff took alot more.

Aside: whats the point of regular when they have the space-age technical ability to make a highly concentrated liquid? I think having a smaller bottle that does the same job as a jug is better value, and less weight.

People hate it when companies eliminate products. You may hate Palmolive regular, but I'm sure some people out there love it.

I'm pretty sure that is what happened, I've seen the big jugs of regular dish detergent at Costco. The ultra is sold in smaller jugs.

[tzcnd]

You pay more because you are guaranteed satisfaction, can return practically anything at practically anytime (which includes, implicitly, great price protection - in case a Costco item drops in price within say six months), and don't need to spend extra for extended warranties (generally - as most problems happen in the first year and you can usually get Costco to take care of that for you).

If you're going to compare Costco prices to places like Loblaws, etc and that's it for your comparison then you're barking up the wrong tree already.

Costco is especially great for electronics and computer shoppers

So very true.

Something might be a little cheaper at another store but can you really put a price on the product satisfaction that Costco provides.

Case in point. In May I buy a 160gig portable HD for $129.99. In June I notice that it has been reduced in price to $119.99 so I go to the service desk and get a $10 + tax price adjustment refund. This week it is offered for $99.99 ($20 off) with a coupon. I again go to the service desk and without question they give me a $20 refund. Name me one other store that would do that.

This is why I shop at Costco. Their service is second to none.

[tzcnd]

Pretty funny reasons for dissing Costco-
considering they take heat in the industry for paying employees more than average and providing benefits,
-more reasons to shop there

Wow what a novel idea. A company that pays a decent wage and benefits and still makes money and still has a very high stock price. Who would have believed it.

Much better than the company that screws their employees every chance they can get in order for them to have mostly not so low prices. Who could I be talking about???:confused: :confused: :confused:

[DaFonz]

Costco is a profit driven company, making record profits each quarter for their shareholders. I don't shop at Costco because its way overpriced, just like their stock.

What a stupid comment - ALL COMPANIES ARE PROFIT DRIVEN.

[patriot]

Costco is a profit driven company, making record profits each quarter for their shareholders. I don't shop at Costco because its way overpriced, just like their stock.

Spoken like a true Sam's Club employee !

[Strikerjs]

... I challenge anyone to tell the difference between PC cola and Coke. When it's on sale, you can get a 24 pack for $3.99.

I hope you put on your flamesuit gojetsgo, because you will get torched for comments like that. :lol:

Just because you don't have tastebuds doesn't mean nobody else does.

[memacmur]

I find Costco great for certain things.

As someone already mentioned - there prices for printer ink are the best I've seen.

The wife is a scrapbooker, and they have had deals on scrapbook paper and Fiskar's scissors that were less then half of what you would pay anywhere else.

Cleaning supplies also seem to be on sale often, and since you can never have too much laying around, I appreciate being able to buy it in volume.

I actually find their electronics prices very hit-and-miss - when they have a deal, it's usually very good. When they don't, there price is very average. Of course, knowing you will have no hassle if something goes wrong with a big-ticket electronics purchase - fantastic.

As for the "everyday" groceries, you have to have a clue what things cost elsewhere. Also, double-check the volume since sometimes you're paying the 'regular' price for 150% the volume. And sometimes your paying 150% the price for 100% the volume (rarely, but it happens). Also, I make note of the coupons, as Costco coupons are generally a good savings - not saving 10 cents here and there.

And I've also found their meat to be great tasting. The 3-pack whole chickens are fantastic. Mmmm, BBQ rotisserie chicken... :lol:

[RaTeD]

Costco's pricing is relatively cheap, to be honest, compared to that of other stores/

[krazy]

:D :D :D Spoken like a true Sam's Club employee !

[belgiangenius]

Costco is just a big scam in my opinion. Pay a yearly membership fee for higher prices. It really speaks to the intelligence of the consuming public.

[tienm23]

Costco is just a big scam in my opinion. Pay a yearly membership fee for higher prices. It really speaks to the intelligence of the consuming public.

Nice troll. We know your not a fan of costco and that you don't feel its good value but for many of us it is. The point is that although Costco is not always the cheapest on every item, it offers great overall value. i.e. Quality, Pricing, Service. The cheapest price isn't the only factor for most people, overall value is.

[Riddick]

Costco is just a big scam in my opinion. Pay a yearly membership fee for higher prices. It really speaks to the intelligence of the consuming public.

Well, I have the executive membership so it works out to be free, given the amount I spend. I go weekly for the staples - milk, eggs, bread, juice, and that stuff really adds up . For the other stuff, I know I can maybe get it a little cheaper if I waited and drove all over the place, but I can get it when I need at Costco without the hassle.

[caliente]

Like anywhere else, you have to know your prices. There are some amazing deals at Costco and some not so good deals. I don't buy canned goods, toilet paper and such at Costco because you can generally find it on sale cheaper elsewhere and I stock up when on sale. You will get good everyday prices on these items but not great prices. There are great deals on clothes, electronics, books, car batteries, small appliances, vitamins, contact lenses and glasses and so much more. Costco is also a fun place to shop as you never know what you'll find.

Their toilet paper is good quality! My roommate is probably even cheaper than most people here. She always buys thin, one-ply toilet paper.

That said, I try to buy regular house goods when they are on sale/coupon. If you can wait it out, these things will eventually be discounted at Costco.

I agree with you completely though. I'm not after the CHEAPEST or BEST deals. And I'm okay with paying a little more for some things if that means one-stop shopping (else I would have to go to Sobey's for the meat that's on sale, Zellers for the toilet paper, etc, etc). Most things are a good and decent price.

Great deals can be had with the weekly discounts and coupons. A lot of the stuff I buy are 'weekly specials'. It's also therapeutic to go to Costco regularly. I know where everything and I have a routine. I start by going to the watch display case to look at a Burberry watch :lol: , then to clothing, books, and eventually to the food.

[feature76]

I honestly rarely find costco to beat out other retailers on cost consistantly. They do have some items worth while but on the whole i think many people are blinded by the bulk sizes.


Where is this mystical stores that sells my 2kg box of granola for cheaper than Costco?
Or my 50pounds of kitty litter for less than $5.
Or my tortellini 3pack for less than 12 bucks?
My 2 1kg loaves of rye bread for 4 bucks.
My 64 granola bars for 12 bucks.

It doesn't exist. That doesn't mean you buy every single item in the store.



Kitty litter - Can't speak for the kitty litter as i have a dog.
2kg box of granola for cheaper than Costco? - Most likely Bulk Barn or any other bulk food store.
Tortellini 3 pack, you don't mention fresh, frozen or brand. But almost ever grocery store beats those prices. By alot.
rye bread - I love my rye bread. $1.39 a loaf local bakery. Easy to find for under 1.79

[patrob]

I hope you put on your flamesuit gojetsgo, because you will get torched for comments like that. :lol:

Just because you don't have tastebuds doesn't mean nobody else does.

:D :D

I drink Coke everyday & there is a HUGE difference in taste vs. PC Cola:rolleyes: ... Maybe if PC Cola would be Free I would drink it...or maybe not...;)

[myapple]

Costco's pricing is relatively cheap, to be honest, compared to that of other stores/
Agreed. Some examples:

Salmon: A large pack that can be cut up to make 4-5 fillet steaks cost $14. Buying one piece alone from dominion is around $5/each.

SD Cards: About two months ago, a 2GB sandisk ultraII flash card was $39. All the computers stores in the area (tiger direct, canada computers) was selling the same card between $45-55.

Ribena Concentrated juice mix: $6.99 at costco. I believe nofrills was selling for $7.99 at no frills and T&T.

2-ton car jack and 2 stands: $20 at costco. Everywhere else (walmart, cdn tire) this set sells for at least $30.

Even over the course of 12 months, the membership fee paid for itself and more.

[zod]

Costco has some products I like that I can't find other places. Their sports socks seem to be of higher quality then ones at RCSS or superstore. They used to sell these boxes that had 4 Thai curry kits in them that I liked (but they seem to have stopped selling them). Sometimes there's a good deal on electronics or a giant folgers coffee.

I find most of the time though, RCSS is cheaper and they do that by selling smaller multiples (which is rather odd). Costco used to be super cheap 10-15 years ago.. but now I just go there because they carry some stuff I can't find elsewhere.

I do like the packs for sanyo rechargable batteries.. i've bought about 3 of those now.. power lots of stuff in the house :)

[JL2002]

well, if something go on clearance in Costco, the .97 ones...it goes deep down....bought like pack of 8 high quality sharp steak knife for like $9.97; x30II Texas Ins. calculator for 9.97; Ipod 2gb Nano for 49.97 etc. I agree that some of the products cost more than some places, but u gotta understand, every store are made that way. They attract ppl with lower priced stuff in order to also get them to buy the high priced one. People don't go to 3 grocery store to get what they need for Dinner, usually they just go to one that's seems to be cheaper and get everything they need.

[Steeve Urkel]

well, if something go on clearance in Costco, the .97 ones...it goes deep down....bought like pack of 8 high quality sharp steak knife for like $9.97; x30II Texas Ins. calculator for 9.97; Ipod 2gb Nano for 49.97 etc. I agree that some of the products cost more than some places, but u gotta understand, every store are made that way. They attract ppl with lower priced stuff in order to also get them to buy the high priced one. People don't go to 3 grocery store to get what they need for Dinner, usually they just go to one that's seems to be cheaper and get everything they need.

I know Costco does have some cheap cosmetics and perfumes for women. I think it was Elizabeth Arden they used to sell, but rewrapped in clear plastic packaging...kinda weird.

Ya, the prices look good- but you never know how old those things are.

Costco does have ok prices for protein bars, or used to anyways.
i used to think that gum was a good deal there at $7 something for 12 packages....but not thesedays- that is pretty average, if not kind of crappy!

[cloneman]

costco very rarely has a price that is higher than average. They might not have the best price for everything, but if you do all your shopping there (instead of all your shopping somewhere else) you will save some money.

There's also the freshness factor. Food can stay on shelves for months, even years in smaller stores. With the kind of volume costco has, you are more likely to get something fresh.

[Crimson]

Agreed. Some examples:

Salmon: A large pack that can be cut up to make 4-5 fillet steaks cost $14. Buying one piece alone from dominion is around $5/each.



Dominion is open 24hr a day, I can buy a flesh piece anytime, 5 pieces from costco? Maybe someone are used to eat stale food all the time, but I am not.


SD Cards: About two months ago, a 2GB sandisk ultraII flash card was $39. All the computers stores in the area (tiger direct, canada computers) was selling the same card between $45-55.


Sandisk is just a rip off, from 2 month ago, a MIJ kingston 2GB microsd is ~$25.

[Crimson]

costco very rarely has a price that is higher than average. They might not have the best price for everything, but if you do all your shopping there (instead of all your shopping somewhere else) you will save some money.

There's also the freshness factor. Food can stay on shelves for months, even years in smaller stores. With the kind of volume costco has, you are more likely to get something fresh.

The fresh food will stay on shelves in your kitchen for weeks. Buy in bulk and eat stale food.

[cloneman]

The fresh food will stay on shelves in your kitchen for weeks. Buy in bulk and eat stale food.

I rather it rots in my kitchen that have it rotten when I buy it. Buy in bulk for things you will actually eat regularly.

[elkhound]

I let my membership die. I hated the long lineups. The meat at my Costco wasn't that great. It was going down hill fast. I bought the roasts and was always getting one perfect one and the other had nasty, tough bits. Fruit and veg were sold in huge quantities that would spoil before we could use it. Cosmetics? Never saw any.

Yes bread and milk were cheaper but my time is also worth money.

[Impossibles]

I let my membership die. I hated the long lineups. The meat at my Costco wasn't that great. It was going down hill fast. I bought the roasts and was always getting one perfect one and the other had nasty, tough bits. Fruit and veg were sold in huge quantities that would spoil before we could use it. Cosmetics? Never saw any.

Yes bread and milk were cheaper but my time is also worth money.

When I lived in Vancouver, the lineups were 30 minutes usually.

Then I moved to Langley (suburbs) and the first time shopping I was shocked by NO LINEUPS AT ALL!!! :-0 I felt wierd because a bunch of cashiers were trying to lure me into their lines.

So what I'm saying is all costco's aren't the same.

[lapopal]

I shop at the Vancouver Costco and rarely wait in line more than 5 min.

[Impossibles]

I shop at the Vancouvr Costco and rarely wait in line more than 5 min.

Which one? The grandview one is horrible.

[LonesomeDove]

Which one? The grandview one is horrible.

I believe he is referring to the downtown one across from GM place. I go there often and the lineup there is 5 minutes or less on weekdays. On Weekends, it is a little busier but probably not more than 10 minutes.

[PangYu]

One great deal IMO at Costco is the price of their egg whites--they sell 2 cartons of 500ml for $3.50. This is almost half the price of every grocery store i've been to. I eat them for breakfast everyday so the savings adds up quickly!

[redkid]

no store can guarantee the lowest price on EVERY product
some stores are better for electronics others for food, others for furniture
they realize that people rather buy everything @ one store so y not try and make a few extra bucks lost on other products on another category ?

[Gdog]

This is a good read if you haven't seen it before...why Costco is so addictive (found the link from Wikipedia) http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2006/10/30/8391725/index.htm?postversion=2006102506

[kaddy69]

One great deal IMO at Costco is the price of their egg whites--they sell 2 cartons of 500ml for $3.50. This is almost half the price of every grocery store i've been to. I eat them for breakfast everyday so the savings adds up quickly!

By far the best deal at cosco.... mmmmm egg white omelette tomorrow morning.

[azlar2007]

I really like their bakery section :D

[ssainani]

I let my membership die. I hated the long lineups. but my time is also worth money.

quoted for truth.

i don't know if i'm annoyed by the lines more...or the rest of the stupid sheep waiting patiently in the line.

i too did not renew

[tienm23]

quoted for truth.

i don't know if i'm annoyed by the lines more...or the rest of the stupid sheep waiting patiently in the line.

i too did not renew

Intresting...so you NEVER stand in line anywhere??

[Porcina]

Would you please tell me what RCSS store is? Nothing comes to mind but I know I will feel foolish for not thinking of it myself.

Just bought a membership. The warehouse size was daunting and I felt overwhelmed by the size and variety. Bought the good tasting feta cheese in large pail, triangle bread, thick steaks for BBQing .Gift food baskets looked good and reasonable and very fresh flowers including roses for $14.99 also looked like a buy.

Thanks for this thread. It will help guide my purchases.

[Impossibles]

Would you please tell me what RCSS store is? Nothing comes to mind but I know I will feel foolish for not thinking of it myself.

Just bought a membership. The warehouse size was daunting and I felt overwhelmed by the size and variety. Bought the good tasting feta cheese in large pail, triangle bread, thick steaks for BBQing .Gift food baskets looked good and reasonable and very fresh flowers including roses for $14.99 also looked like a buy.

Thanks for this thread. It will help guide my purchases.

Real Canadian SuperStore

[Impossibles]

quoted for truth.

i don't know if i'm annoyed by the lines more...or the rest of the stupid sheep waiting patiently in the line.

i too did not renew

Where is the magical store with no lineups?

[hagbard]

quoted for truth.

i don't know if i'm annoyed by the lines more...or the rest of the stupid sheep waiting patiently in the line.

i too did not renew

My mother trained me early by having me stand in line at Expo 67 (those were waits of up to six hours). Then all we got was gov't propaganda from around the world, at Costco we get nice toys.

[Steeve Urkel]

Just a small warning.

I had to evaluate the employees at a Costco last week and some of them were really not good.

A few of the food stand emplyees actually told me the dish- antipasto I was trying was "really good and all vegetables" now I hate fish unless it is fresh, never buy canned stuff...

So, when i actually picked up the package I saw TUNA was an ingredient.
They also did not have their food alleregy warning labels out..another mistake!

So, if you have any food issues, be careful as the people they hire seem to be a lot of "non english" speaking people.

Thankfully I am not allergic to fish.

Also another lady tried the same dish at the same time and she was very mad the lady at the counter told her it was vegetables only.....really not cool!

[Gdog]

Just a small warning.

I had to evaluate the employees at a Costco last week and some of them were really not good.

A few of the food stand emplyees actually told me the dish- antipasto I was trying was "really good and all vegetables" now I hate fish unless it is fresh, never buy canned stuff...

So, when i actually picked up the package I saw TUNA was an ingredient.
They also did not have their food alleregy warning labels out..another mistake!

So, if you have any food issues, be careful as the people they hire seem to be a lot of "non english" speaking people.

Thankfully I am not allergic to fish.

Also another lady tried the same dish at the same time and she was very mad the lady at the counter told her it was vegetables only.....really not cool!

Those food sample workers are from an outsourced company...I sometimes question their handling practices, so I go for selective samples (aka Jelly Belly beans)