PDA

View Full Version : Toilet Explodes While in Use - Man Sues for Damages


felix
Jun 3rd, 2005, 04:25 AM
You guys who smoke need to be more careful! :)

MORGANTOWN, W.Va. - A Pennsylvania man injured when a portable toilet exploded is suing a general contractor and a coal company for negligence.

John Jenkins, 53, and his wife Ramona Jenkins, 35, of Brave, Pa., filed the lawsuit in Monongalia County Circuit Court on Tuesday. They are suing Chisler Inc., a general contractor from Fairview, and Eastern Associated Coal Corp. for $10 million in damages.

The explosion occurred July 13, 2004, at Parrish Shaft in Blacksville. Jenkins, a North West Fuels Development Inc. methane power plant operator, entered a portable toilet, sat down and tried to light a cigarette.

"When I struck the lighter, the whole thing just detonated - the whole top blew off," John Jenkins said. "I can't tell you if it blew me out the door or if I jumped out."

The lawsuit says the cigarette ignited methane gas leaking from a pipe underneath the unit.

Eastern Associated Coal Corp. owns the property where the explosion occurred. Chisler Inc. ran over the pipelines with heavy equipment before the incident, causing the methane gas leak, Jenkins alleges.

The lawsuit also says there was no sign on the portable toilet warning that smoking, matches and open flames were forbidden.

Jenkins had severe burns on his face, neck, arms, torso and legs. He is permanently disfigured, the lawsuit says.

Eastern Associated Coal is a subsidiary of Peabody Energy. A call to that company's Charleston office was not immediately returned Thursday. A man who answered the phone at Chisler's office in Fairview said he was familiar with the lawsuit and the company would have no comment. He would not give his name.

source: http://start.earthlink.net/article/str?guid=20050602/429e8440_3ca6_1552620050602-1857951709

Absolute
Jun 3rd, 2005, 05:48 AM
What a dumbass, it was probably his own gas that caused the explosion.

Rogue_77
Jun 3rd, 2005, 06:51 AM
Saw something like that on mythbusters, in order for it to blow, you'd literally have to have no air flow in the toilet and alot of gas in there for it to ignite. The guys on the show basically busted the myth

MizTEcK
Jun 3rd, 2005, 08:20 AM
if its a myth why did this guy get owned? :cheesygri

spidermoore
Jun 3rd, 2005, 09:23 AM
if its a myth why did this guy get owned? :cheesygri

It was a portable toilet, which I assume is one of those portable outhouse type things. They can contain a large amount of crap in the bottom from several "donors". Methane buildup?

simms
Jun 3rd, 2005, 10:14 AM
I dunno about this one, he should deserve some money but not that much.

There is no law against smoking in a toilet, and he wasn't at fault in doing so.

simms
Jun 3rd, 2005, 10:15 AM
It was a portable toilet, which I assume is one of those portable outhouse type things. They can contain a large amount of crap in the bottom from several "donors". Methane buildup?

Probably would be insignificant due to the fact it was overtop a methane mining operation of sorts. That probably had greater contribution to the explosion than just fecal matter.